r/StudentLoanSupport • u/BabiesLoveStrayDogs • 13h ago
2 Direct Consolidation Loans - are they "consolidated"
This feels like a dumb question, but when using the loan calculator on StudentAid, all the talk about the benefits and drawbacks of consolidation on your potential repayment plans is confusing me.
I am currently on SAVE and preparing for the next step within 90 days, as I got my email from MOHELA last week.
I am eligible for PSLF, and want to maintain that eligibility.
My first loans originated in 2000, according to studentaid.gov, though I know I took loans before then in the late 90's (I attended university full time starting in 1998 with Federal loans). I always had subsidized and unsubsidized loans.
I consolidated my loans (I thought) in 2019 to join the SAVE repayment plan, but that resulted in TWO Direct Consolidation Loans (Subsidized and Unsubsidized)
What you see in the pic is where I am with all this almost 26 years later.
In the Repayment Calculator, the interface is confusing... there are two buttons above the results which say "PSLF on" and "Consolidation on" and I can't tell if they are indicating that the results you see are with those options ARE turned on or if you have to click the buttons to turn those options on.
Anyway, with the PSLF button clicked, nothing appears to change in terms of eligible plans I can move to. With the Consolidation button presumably ON, I get fewer options and the RAP plan is slightly higher monthly payments with slightly longer terms, and higher interest.
I can't tell which version of the RAP plan applies to my loan set up! With the ability to see all possible worlds, but the inability to distinguish the options based on your actual loan structure, I'm just bloody confused.
If there's a detail that I can share that would help indicate the correct answer let me know, but if anyone can enlighten me based on what I provided here I would appreciate your help so much. Thanks in advance.