Hello!
I hadn't watched Law & Order: SVU since I was a teenager and when I saw it on Netflix I decided to give it another shot, especially the newer seasons.
First, I don't remember if it was always like this, but this episode felt very poorly written. The culprit turns out to be someone we've never even met before (a completely random guy who shows up in the last three minutes). Maybe I'm too used to Agatha Christie's Poirot where the killer is actually someone introduced earlier but the whole time I was trying to figure out whether it was Erik or the father.
Speaking of Erik, that interrogation felt really odd. I don't remember Olivia and Elliot jumping to so many wild assumptions to his face right away. It came across as amateurish interrogation. And why didn't Erik immediately mention that he had worked at the foster home or that he had been Mackenzie's tutor? Instead, he made it sound like he had just met her at the train station and bought her a soda because she seemed nice (???). Then while he's about to be accused of possessing child sexual abuse material he starts asking Olivia about her marital status? I mean even before he was cleared lol. That was so bizarre.
When they found Ella they just... took her home? I would have expected her to be interviewed first and for the parents to come to the station instead. Also ten years later she's an adult. It felt weird that they simply reunited her with her parents. For all we know she could have run away from them voluntarily.
Overall, it felt like the writers didn't really know where they wanted the episode to go and eventually had to wrap it up after squeezing everything they could out of Mackenzie's storyline.
I honestly remember the older episodes being much better constructed.
Can anyone tell me if the next episodes improve?
And what did you think of this one? (aside from the open ending. By that point it wasn't even the most facepalm-worthy part of the episode.)