This happened during a small league game. I don't groan usually, but I begin to make grunting sound for fast hard shots as my stamina runs out after ~2 hours of playing. Some of it is unintended sound.
They didn't call the claim for the drive shot. But they claim that during a particular kitchen line fire fight. I didn't make a sound when I bring wrist flick, then opponent countered with block, and then I make a sound when I bring semi overhead against the fast block to my chest~shoulder level. Then his reset against my semi overhead popped up, then he calls the noise fault on me and immediately stopped playing for that point. He shouted it really loud when he said "noise fault."
He claims with the rule regarding intentional distractions with excessive, unnatural noises. But I made the sound only when I hit the ball, not when he hit the ball. But he claims that I was grunting long and I was still grunting, which was loud enough to be heard, when he hit the ball. But it is just what he says without evidences. I don't think my grunting was that long, it is just his claim. But I admit that it was kitchen line fire fight exchange and I agree the ball was very fast...
We didn't record, and this is a small local league of a small town club, so no refs at all. But I swear to god, I never received any claims regarding excessive noise when I play league or tournament or rec play so far.
We never reached the agreement. So, according to the rule, we replayed the point again. But my mental was shaken because I was annoyed, so I mess up and lost the game that we were winning.
Is his claim legit? I feel like he was just pushing an unreasonable demands to change the mood and create a mental war, which I become hooked. It is my fault that I messed up my mental game but I still think the call was ridiculous because I didn't make the noise when he hit the ball. Even if my grunting was long, it was not that loud, he was just nitpicking, but I admit this is just what I think.
So I wonder, is his claim legit?