I’m completely at a loss and would appreciate advice from anyone who has dealt with something similar.
Like many borrowers, I was previously enrolled in SAVE. Last year, I successfully switched to PAYE because I had a partial financial hardship at the time.
Since then, my income increased, and I no longer meet the old partial-financial-hardship test. I was nervous about recertification, but my understanding was that I could remain on PAYE and my payment would simply be capped at the 10-year standard repayment amount.
EdFinancial confirmed that I was enrolled in automatic recertification because I had authorized access to my IRS information. I later received a message telling me to submit annual recertification paperwork, but when I called, I was told everything was fine because my IRS data was already linked.
As my anniversary date approached, I anxiously waited to see what would happen. I was incredibly relieved when my payment updated to the PAYE 10-year capped amount that had previously been calculated.
That relief lasted one month.
EdFinancial then moved me from PAYE into IBR. At first, I thought that was fine because I expected my payment to remain around the same capped amount.
Instead, I was moved to the standard repayment plan because EdFinancial said I was no longer eligible for PAYE.
For anyone wondering why the standard plan would be a problem: my loans are unconsolidated, and this is not the same as the 10-year standard amount used as the PAYE payment cap. EdFinancial calculated my standard payment using the number of payments it believes I have left in the original repayment schedule. Certain forbearance periods, including the COVID pause, apparently were not included in that calculation. So even though I have approximately 108 qualifying PSLF months, EdFinancial is calculating my payment as though I have around 63 payments remaining. That caused my monthly payment to jump to nearly double what I would have paid under the PAYE cap.
I contacted EdFinancial again. Multiple representatives acknowledged that I apparently should not have been removed from PAYE. However, they told me the easiest solution would be to apply for old IBR. They said I should qualify and offered two months of administrative forbearance that would count toward PSLF while the application was processed.
That seemed reasonable—until I submitted the application and EdFinancial told me I now qualify for no income-driven repayment plan at all.
I have spoken with multiple senior representatives who said they would send the issue to the back office. I cited the new legislation and the relevant statutory provisions stating that old IBR no longer requires a partial financial hardship. I also asked how they could claim I am ineligible for every IDR plan when RAP should eventually be available, even though RAP is not the plan I am currently trying to enter.
Despite all of that, I keep being dismissed because my salary increased.
I’m now facing a payment that is nearly twice the PAYE-capped amount, even though I am only about a year away from 120 qualifying PSLF payments.
What should I do next?
Should I:
-File a complaint with the Federal Student Aid Ombudsman?
- Submit a paper IDR application?
-File a formal complaint through StudentAid.gov?
-Contact my congressional representative or senator’s constituent-services office?
-Keep pushing EdFinancial to restore me to PAYE rather than applying for IBR?
Has anyone successfully fixed a situation where a servicer incorrectly removed them from PAYE or denied old IBR because they did not have a partial financial hardship?
At this point, I feel like I have done everything correctly and am still being penalized for servicer errors. I’m exhausted and honestly wondering whether I should give up. I’ve spent hours and hours away from my young family working on this and am feeling so demoralized.