hi all!
i need help because i feel like i have been staring at so many bags and don’t know what to get to change up my current travel bag.
for context, I have been travelling with a gregory border 40 for the last few years and love it - the only reason I'm looking for a new bag is because I'm learning how to condense what I bring and feel like I could do with a bit less space, and that the bag kinda looks and feels massive on me (I am 5'4"F) with a short torso.
now here's what i've been looking at:
I started with looking at the cotopaxi allpa 28L, and while I loved it and feel like I could make it work, I think its a bit too small for what I want. I bought it, did some test packing, and some heavy contemplation, and decided I think its pushing it for my level of one bagging and I like the freedom of a bit of a bigger bag in the case of buying things abroad and couldn't justify the price while being slightly unsure of making it work.
My next idea was the forclaz 500 40L from decathlon - because maybe the compression straps would help with the space that I could make the bag smaller when I have less, but have room to expand. I know this one is the same height as the gregory border 40, but it checked like literally all the other boxes (love that it has similar internal organization, compression straps and lots of misc. organization pockets) that I wanted so I thought I would check it out; it feels too tall on me, and ultimately I just like the way my gregory feels to pack, wear, to zip open and shut, etc. more.
So now I've sort of come to the understanding I need something over 30L and under 40L as a sweet spot - and I'm trying to find something a little more on the budget side as I would rather not drop a ton on a bag right now...
I looked at the COR Surf Island Hopper 2.0 34L, which I actually think might be a decent fit while being shorter than the border 40 but a bit over than I want to spend right now especially seeing mixed reviews on the quality of the bag holding up over time (open to opinions if anyone has this bag and if its worth going a bit over budget for)
I of course know of the cotopaxi allpa 35, but with the dimensions being so similar and price point being high at that point I would just keep my gregory 40.
I've also looked at the gregory border 30, which doesn't really solve the height issue but i love my 40L so much so maybe an option, but also worried 30L exactly might be too small
And lastly the gregory border 35 which is looking like a fairly ideal bag for what I want (despite maybe being a bit too deep for carry on req. from what I'm seeing?) but I would have to do some scouring for it second hand online (if anyone is looking to get rid of theirs I may happily buy it off of you!!)
essentially, what I want out of a bag is
- somewhere over 30L and under 40L (aiming for 35L)
- somewhere around 48-50cm tall (or less)
- clamshell opening while being able to pack on both sides (I don't like one big pocket bags and love the internal organization where I can put clothes on one side and everything else in the other)
- relatively budget friendly (aiming for like $150 CAD)
- I'm ok with no hip belt if I have to get rid of that to meet some of my other points
Should I just stick with my gregory, look more into any of the bags I listed, or do you know of another one that might fit with what I'm looking for? Am I looking for something that doesn't exist? Thanks in advance !!