r/ModelY Apr 24 '26

Essentials For Washing Your Model Y & Wolfbox MF200 Giveaway

3 Upvotes

Where I live it is nearly impossible to find a touchless car wash and the one that is 15 miles away uses very harsh chemicals and is closed quite frequently. My preferred approach is to wash my car at home and I wanted to help share the best products I could find that may work for you.

There two ways to approach washing your Model Y, the traditional soap and water or going rinseless. Each one has some pro's and con's and you will ultimately have to decide which way works for you.

Trying to decide between a traditional soap + water wash vs a rinseless wash for keeping your car clean? I’ve been comparing both methods, so here’s a breakdown for anyone researching car wash routines.

Traditional Soap + Water Wash

This is the classic method most people think of when washing a car.

Typical Products Used:

Pros:

  • Best for heavily dirty vehicles (mud, salt, sand, bug buildup, road grime)
  • Running water helps flush abrasive debris before touching paint
  • Easier to clean wheel wells, lower panels, suspension components

Cons:

  • Uses much more water
  • Requires driveway/hose access
  • Harder/impossible in winter or apartment living
  • Can leave water spots if not dried quickly

Rinseless Wash

This method uses a concentrated rinseless wash solution mixed in water. You wash panel-by-panel using microfiber towels or a mitt, then dry without needing a final rinse.

Typical Products Used:

Pros:

  • Very low water usage
  • Fast and convenient
  • Great for apartments/garages/winter washing
  • Lower chance of water spotting

Cons:

  • Not ideal for thick mud or heavy grit
  • Requires good towel discipline (swap towels often)
  • More microfiber laundry afterward

Curious what everyone here prefers and why. Traditional? Rinseless? Hybrid setup? Or do you skip all of this and just go to a car wash?

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Giveaway of Wolfbox MF200

Microfiber clothes work great for drying large areas on the Model Y, but can't reach everywhere. The go to product I use to blow water out from behind the mirror, seals, door jams, etc is a Wolfbox MF200. I made a full review video of the MF200 and cover what else you can use it for (replacing canned air dusters, electronics, filters, etc).

Wolfbox is holding an Overlanding Sale from April 21st - May 10th and reached out to me to host a giveaway for 3 MF200 Enduro Pack's. You can also save $10 off anything from Wolfbox using code "WBMMYA".

Giveaway Details

  • I’ll randomly select winners from the comments using Reddit Raffler
  • Make a comment below on what you would use the MF200 for
  • I’ll DM the winners once the giveaway closes on May 1st, 2026 at 12 PM CST
  • Winners will receive 1 MF200 Enduro Pack

Giveaway Eligibility: First just to cover some rules on this, you must be 18 years or older and live within the United States (continental area only) and your Reddit account must be at least 30 days old. Wolfbox will provide 3 winners a MF200 Enduro Pack and I will reach out to the winners via Reddit, if you do not respond within 1 week another raffle will occur to draw a new winner. Redditraffler will be used to track the giveaway and the link to determine the winners will be provided in a comment below once the entry period is over. 

I may earn a commission when you purchase through links on the Wolfbox website. However, this does not influence my review or recommendations and all opinions are my own.


r/ModelY Apr 10 '26

2026 Guide to Model Y Accessories

129 Upvotes

For the last two years I have created guides to accessories (2025 & 2024) on accessories for all Model Y variants. Have an accessory to share that you find useful that isn't in the list below, add a comment and I can add it!

If you are purchasing anything from Amazon and are not already an Amazon Prime member you can join here. There are typically discounts for students and young adults.

Discount Codes

Using discount code Adventure or MyAdventure will save more compared to any of the codes available on any of the links below.

Charging

Item Description Link Legacy Model Y Model Y Juniper
Tesla Wall Connector From Amazon Y Y
Tesla Universal Wall Connector From Amazon Y Y
Tesla Mobile Connector From Amazon Y Y

Wheels & Rim Covers

Item Description Link Legacy Model Y Model Y Juniper
Martian Wheels - MW08 Martian Wheels Y Y
Martiwn Wheels - MW05 Martian Wheels Y Y
Martian Wheels - MW03 Martian Wheels Y Y
Uberturbine 21 Wheel Cover Rim Protector From Amazon Y N
Juniper Performance Rim Protectors 21 Inch Wheel From EVBase N Performance Model
20" Wheel Cover Rim Protector From Amazon, Hansshow, Tesstudio Y Y
20" Helix Wheel Covers From Yeslak N Y
19" Gemini Wheel Covers From EVBase N Y
19" Arachnid Crossflow Wheel Covers From Tesstudio N Y
19" Crossflow Wheel Rim Protector From EVBase, Yeslak N Y
19" Turbine Wheel Covers From Tesstudio, Yeslak Y Y
Touch Up Wheel Paint from Jowua Y Y

External Accessories

Item Description Link Legacy Model Y Model Y Juniper
Rear Door Paint Protection Film From Tesla Y Y
Mudflaps (Legacy Model Y) From Amazon (Legacy) and Amazon (Juniper) Y Y
Mudflaps (Juniper) From Amazon or From EVBase N Y
Front Camera PPF From DIY Wrap Club N Y
Front Camera Protector Cover From Amazon (Ricoh Theta SC2 version) N Y
Ceramic Coating From Amazon Y Y
Paint Repair Kit From Tesla or Jowua Y Y
Magnetic Tow Hitch Cover From Amazon Y N
Silent Tow Hitch Pin From Amazon Y Y
Front License Plate Quick Mount From Amazon Y N
Front License Plate Quick Mount From Teslarati Y Y
Front License Plate Quick Mount From Amazon N Y
Model Y License Plate Frame From Tesla or on Amazon Y Y
Powered Frunk From Hansshow (for legacy Model Y) and from Hansshow (Juniper) Y Y
Carbon Fiber Mirror Covers From Hansshow Y N
Portable Tire Inflator From Amazon Y Y
Jack Pads / Lifting Pucks From Amazon Y Y
Brake Caliper Covers From EVBase or Hansshow N Y
MyQ Garage Door Hub From Amazon Y Y
Internal Frunk LED Strip From Pimp My EV Y Unknown
Starlink Taillight From Tes Studio Y N
Black Out Badges Dual Motor Badge from Pimp My EV T logo from Amazon Y Y (badge only)
Auto Presenting RGB Door Handles From Tes Studio Y Y
Front Lip Splitter From EVBase Y Y
Side Skirts From EVBase Y Y
Rear Diffuser From EVBase Y Y
Yofer Body Kit From EV Base N Y

Interior Accessories

Item Description Link Legacy Model Y Model Y Juniper
3W Floor Mats From 3W (Legacy) and 3W (Juniper) Y Y
Emergency Door Release Strap From Jowua Y Y
New Owners Bundle From Teslarati Y Y
Ceramic Coating - Leather Shield (for seats) From Amazon Y Y
Seat Cleaning Products From Amazon (soap) and from Amazon (microfiber towels) Y Y
HVAC Under Seat Vent Mesh Covers From Amazon Y Y
Ventilated Performance Seats From EV Offer Y Y
Screen Swivel Mount From Tes Studio Y Y
Front Screen Protector Legacy Model Y from Amazon & Model Y Juniper from Amazon OR combo kit for Model Y Juniper from Amazon and for the new 16" from Tesery Y Y
Rear Screen Protector From Amazon N Y
Under Seat Storage Container From Amazon Y N
MagSafe Wireless Phone Charger From MagBak Y Y
Carplay Adapter From EV Offer Y N
Seat Protectors From Amazon Y Y
Car Seat Protector From Amazon Y Y
Tablet/Phone Holder From Amazon Y Y
Ambient Lights From Lightingbug Tech Y Y
Seat Belt Guide Holder From Amazon Y N
Center Console Cover From Amazon Y Y (must choose new version)
HDMI Interface From EV Offer Y N
Starlink Mini Mount From Amazon Y Y
Power Station From AllPowers Y Y
Motorized Sunshade From Hansshow Y Y
Flexible Sunshade Roof only or a Complete Set from Jowua Y Y
3D Maxpider All Weather Floor Mats From Teslarati or from Amazon (floor mats) and Amazon (rear cargo) Y Y
Generic Brand All Weather Floor Mats From Amazon (Non-Juniper) and Amazon (Juniper) Y Y
Rear Seat Back Protector From Amazon Y Y
Center Console Organizer From Amazon (center console only) or from Amazon (center console and armrest organizer) or from Amazon (hidden storage) Y N
Center Console Organizer From Amazon (center console only) or from Amazon (armrest organizer) or from Amazon (hidden storage) N Y
Under Screen Storage From Amazon Y N
Under Screen Storage From Amazon N Y
Rear Side Storage Bins From EVBase N Y
Generic Floor Mats From Amazon (Legacy) and Amazon (Juniper) Y Y
Trunk LED Strip From Tes Studio Y Y
Ctrl-Bar From Amazon Y N
Dual Image Puddle Lights From Pimp My EV Y Y
Dashboard Display Screen & Front Camera From Hansshow Legacy Model Y and Hansshow Juniper Y Y
Illuminated Door Sills From Pimp My EV Y Unknown
Rear Entertainment Screen From Tes Studio Y N
Custom Carbon Fiber Steering Wheel From Pimp My EV Y Unknown
Yoke Steering Wheel From Hansshow (Legacy) and Hansshow (Juniper) Y Y
Blind Spot Monitoring From Tes Studio Y N
Mattress From Havnby (Autolevel) From Havnby (Air+Foam) Y Y
S3XY Knob From Enhance Auto or EVOffer Y Y
S3XY Buttons From Enhance Auto or EVOffer Y Y
S3XY Dash From Enhance Auto Y Y
Sub Trunk Fridge From Amazon or Tlyard Y N
Generic 12v Fridge From BougeRV on Amazon Y Y
Rear Cubby Fridge From Tes Studio Y Y

The links above are affiliate links, it costs you nothing additional to use them and helps me out to create more content for you in this subreddit.


r/ModelY 4h ago

Delivery Finally got delivery date!

Post image
70 Upvotes

Ordered July 9 (socal) and estimate was 3-4 weeks. Few days later app updated to say July 15-July 29. On July 15 it got pushed back to July 17-July 31. On July 17 it got pushed back again to July 22-August 5 and I got super sad!!

Then July 22 I got a random text a Tesla Advisor saying they’re trying my best to deliver my car. I asked for an update and they said to just keep checking the app and they don’t have a better ETA. Then that evening I got a VIN! And then this morning I was able to get an appointment.

I got a Model Y Premium AWD in Quicksilver! Scrambled to get everything together to sell my car tonight at Carvana and will go pick up the Y tomorrow!! Literally I was refreshing the app 10+ times a day it was getting unhealthy. Now looking to get tinting done and placed an order of Super Liner mats!


r/ModelY 31m ago

FSD 14.0 Lite is an absolute blessing to receive.

Upvotes

Even after using it on a single drive I’ve noticed so many improvements. First, it gets up to speed much quicker and safer. It seems to go quicker on green lights too. It stays perfectly 7-8 mph over the speed limit as I set it as. Seems more responsive too on cars going across the lane into mine too. Lastly, being able to start FSD from a parking spot is something I didn’t realize I’d love so much. 10/10 update.


r/ModelY 6h ago

2022 MY LR - noises at 15k miles

3 Upvotes

I have a 2022 MY LR and I am original owner and am getting noises:

- a single click/mild clunk on acceleration and on deceleration. Tesla said its the lubrication for the half-axels which could be from heavy acceleration or a lot of stop and go traffic (neither of which I have going on) Tesla said it’s a maintenance item and not covered by warranty- seems unfair to me.

-an interior clicking noise coming from the far left dashboard area- (maybe the AC?)

Is it normal for all these noises at such low mileage?

Am I in for more noises, vibrations etc. in the future?


r/ModelY 4h ago

Question MYP Getting Wrapped!

2 Upvotes

Hello! Just took delivery of my 26 MYP Quicksilver this morning. Took it right to my guy for full body stealth ppf. He’s got the mobile connector he can use to charge.

In the interim, to preserve battery, do I turn off cabin overheat protection? Is there anything else I need to do to preserve battery?

It’s sitting outside of the bay until this evening when he can pull out the car he’s finishing and put mine inside. Just wanna make sure I’m doing this right lol. First time EV owner btw!


r/ModelY 2h ago

Moving from Canada to Texas: Green Card holder locking in promo APR without US Drivers License yet?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I am in the middle of relocating from Canada to Texas and want to take advantage of the current promotional interest rate for a new Tesla.

I hold a US Green Card, but I do not have a Texas Driver's License yet (still using my Canadian driver's license until I land). I have a few specific questions regarding registration, financing, and delivery:

  1. Driver's License for Registration: Can I proceed with the initial registration step in the app using my Canadian Driver's License or US Green Card? Has anyone had a Sales Advisor manually override this in the backend if the app requires a state ID?
  2. Locking in Promo Rates: Does placing the initial order lock in eligibility for the promotional APR rate, or do I risk losing it if my financing application takes extra time due to cross-border verification?
  3. Financing Application ID Requirements: I lived in the US for 6 years previously and have an established US credit history with a 750+ credit score. Since I do not currently hold an active US Driver's License, can I use my US Green Card as primary government-issued ID for financing, or do US auto lenders strictly require a state driver's license?
  4. Postponing Delivery Window: The app quotes a 3 to 4 week delivery timeline for Houston, but I might need to push pickup back by 2 to 3 weeks until I physically arrive in Texas. How flexible is Tesla with pausing delivery, and does unassigning a VIN put the promotional APR rate at risk?

Appreciate any advice or insights from anyone who has navigated a similar situation!


r/ModelY 19h ago

Ready to buy my first EV/Tesla. Some questions for a no0b?

15 Upvotes

In between o40 soccer games last week my buddy drove me to Wawa for waters in his FSD Tesla. It blew my mind. This friend is very very well off and I thought it was cool but always assumed Tesla's were like $80,000-$100,000 cars.

The next day I flew to Atlanta for a seminar where my cousin picked me and my buddy up in his new FSD Tesla. And my buddy as soon as we got in the car told him he just got one too and loves it.

Honestly the price tag is what sold me most, plus currently 0% financing for the RWD which I really love. The car seems like it does so much and the price tag seems so insanely reasonable. Some questions before I jump in though:

1) Is the "order online" price the same you will get at a dealership? It's so refreshing to see a haggle free actual price that you can buy on the spot. Do prices fluctuate at all at actual dealerships?

2) Is there a reason to buy from a dealership vs. just directly buying online? Can you save on the delivery fee if you buy direct from a dealership? The two dealerships in New Jersey are an hour away each.

3) I live in a house in the New Jersey suburbs but do NOT have a garage. It gets very cold here for about 4-5 months of the year and we get snow a few times almost every winter. Will owning a Tesla be a problem in a cold weather climate without a garage? I've read that battery life will be decreased while it's actually cold out, which is fine, but will it kill the long term life of the battery as well?

4) RWD v. AWD. From what I read it seems like the RWD actually performs pretty well and AWD isn't really necessary for the $5K + 0.99% financing price difference?

5) What does seem recommended is the winter tires? I don't see this as an option on Tesla's website when ordering but did read that you can have Tesla put them on? Necessary or not really?

6) Family. I have 2 kids and thus 2 car seats. How do the Tesla seats hold up to the wear and tear of two kids and two car seats?

7) Is the trade in value on the Tesla site you get for putting in the VIN number accurate? Or can you get something different at a dealership? (Or do they just also plug in your VIN number?)

8) Tax credits in NJ? Are they a thing other than the $1,000 NJ rebate Tesla has checked on the website?

9) How is the sound system on the RWD model? I've always bought limited versions of my other cars for the upgraded sound system but the models the basic Y RWD are over my budget.

I'm sure there's more questions I'm forgetting right now but anything else you think I should know or take into consideration is much appreciated. I love the FSD mode. I love the rave mode. I'm falling more and more in love with this car everyday the longer I've been away from it. Thanks so much!


r/ModelY 17h ago

What does it mean when the EDD disappears!?

Post image
7 Upvotes

EDD was July 22-23…. I texted advisor this morning he said he will reach out when it arrives… now the app doesn’t have an EDD anymore!?


r/ModelY 8h ago

New to EVs — is 90-94% battery health normal for 2024/2025 Model Y Performance with under 15k miles?

0 Upvotes

Hey all, I’m new to the EV world and doing my homework before buying used. I’ve been browsing Tesla’s used inventory, specifically 2024 and 2025 Model Y Performance with less than 15,000 miles on them. A lot of the listings show estimated range around 253-260 miles, which works out to roughly 90-94% of original battery capacity.

That seems like a lot of degradation for such low mileage and a car that’s only 1-2 years old. A few questions for those more experienced with EVs:

• Is this range/degradation normal for Model Y Performance this age and mileage, or does it seem high to you?  
• Does anyone know exactly how Tesla calculates the range shown on used listings — is it rated range at 100% charge, or something else?  
• What’s a reasonable benchmark for degradation on a car like this (low mileage, 1-2 years old)?

Appreciate any insight — trying to make sure I’m not missing something obvious as a first-time EV buyer.


r/ModelY 1d ago

Lets go! Rnd 2 of MYP.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/ModelY 1d ago

Question Delivery scheduled over 13 days ago, car still in transit?

Post image
18 Upvotes

What's up y'all? You've probably seen me hanging around the sub in the comments, I made my own posts when I ordered my Model Y premium RWD white on black, anyways, I ordered it July 3rd and 6 days later, I scheduled delivery for July 30th, it's July 22nd and the car is still in transit to the delivery location, I'm wondering if this is normal and you guys have also experienced this or if this is a sign of something


r/ModelY 1d ago

My FSD is becoming super aggressive with me looking away even for a second. Is anyone else having this issue?

9 Upvotes

When I first got my car a couple months ago, I hardly ever heard beeps from “looking away” from the road. Now, even if I look away for 2 seconds it beeps at me. I’ll literally look at my mirrors and immediately it beeps. Looking at my cars screen, beeps right away. What the hell is going on. This is honestly pretty frustrating and I’m getting annoyed with it because 2 days ina row I’ve gotten strikes just by looking at my mirrors. This happens with or without sunglasses on. Also happens even if my phone is out of sight and I’m just checking my mirrors.


r/ModelY 5h ago

Cover for rear screen

0 Upvotes

I just picked up a MYP. Is there a way to cover the rear screen? My 7 year old daughter doesn’t have any screens. I know we can lock it out but when I go to adjust the AC, the apps will show and it’ll be a challenging to keep her from being constantly curious about it -


r/ModelY 20h ago

Model y roof rack

2 Upvotes

2023 model y thinking about getting a roof rack for 2 kayaks, worried about cracking the roof glass should I have Tesla install? How much range is truly lost when hulling. Anything to look out for? should I get a “Tesla” brand one? Any help is appreciated!


r/ModelY 20h ago

New Model Y

2 Upvotes

Hi All,

Getting a 2026 Model Y Premium AWD. Located in NJ and pickup in "Tesla Totowa". Based on VIN its an Austin TX build.

Has anybody that has picked up a MY from NJ or specifically Totowa location recently received front mud guards and rear bumper PPF (I have read on a few forums that in the north east region MY gets these options installed but the advisor didn't know anything about it)?

Regarding the glass protection and tire protection, again I read somewhere that you get it included for the first 14 days at which point you can elect to add it to your account without inspection if you do it within 14 days? Has anybody picked up a Tesla in July and had that included in their account? Again advisor is not aware of this but read this across multiple forums.

I have been reading the inspection checklists so aware of the lists online, but any tips on recent deliveries / pickup in July with things that I should look out for during the pickup inspection and while driving for the first few miles?

Lastly, is there still a no question ask repair/replacement service for the first 7 days, 1 day, or is that not applicable at all anymore in case you find issues after pickup and discover them at home?

Thanks!


r/ModelY 1d ago

Actually using the Windshield Protection Plan is annoying & painful. Is this just my region (NYC/LI) or what?

4 Upvotes

I consider myself super unlucky with windshields. I maintain a pretty far back distance and don't drive behind work trucks but random stuff keeps parabolically chipping or cracking my windshield over the years.

I got the WPP because it seemed easy enough and it would stop 1nsurance claims (in NY, any claim, even glass, over $1000 is reported to CLUE and us3d against you in premiums—WPP is not 1nsurance so avoid CLUE reports).

However, the two times I've tried to use it over the year (once a large crack, another just a chip) has resulted in arguments with the service center. The first time, which was a large crack and needing replacement, they kept trying to charge me the $100 deductible despite the plan saying the first one within a calendar year is free. I had to argue as the service center manager kept saying they're required to charge $100 for every time they work on a windshield.

It took half a day of arguing after my car was completed that I didn't owe it and it was against the contract I signed with Tesla. They finally relented after I guess I just got annoying enough.

Today, I brought my car to a different service center for a chip repair and the same exact issue came up. They said "the system says it's $100 deductible for crack repair". I had to bring up the agreement paperwork, and Tesla's own website, to show that there's unlimited free chip repairs. A lot of back and fourth until the employee said "I'll goodwill it this time, but that's not what the system says".

What's going on? Why is this so difficult? I know I'm not reading the terms wrong. It just adds more annoyance to already dealing with poor Tesla service.


r/ModelY 1d ago

All those who ordered standard versions, how many times do you keep checking the app for updates

2 Upvotes

I ordered a standard RWD (white exterior, back interior and 18 inch wheels) on June 29th in DFW, Texas.

The ETA for me is Oct 11 to Nov 22.

Has anyone else who ordered a standard RWD Model Y experienced long delivery times?

I called Tesla showrooms for updates and they kind of promise that the car would be delivered way sooner. In this subreddit, I see majority order premium models and they are getting their cars fairly quickly.

I wanted to know if others also facing delays with getting their standard Model y.

I have to admit I’ve been checking the Tesla app a little too often because I’m excited for delivery


r/ModelY 2d ago

Question Carwash membership

Post image
183 Upvotes

Picked up a new carwash membership for a steal for unlimited washes for $10/mth for 6 months. Normally $45. It's a new location but it is touch. We are everyone's thoughts on touch carwashes. I intend to go at least once a week.


r/ModelY 1d ago

FSD LITE issue

1 Upvotes

I just upgraded to FSD 14 Lite last night and while it’s super cool to have new features in my HW3 car, it feels more jerky like it is struggling to make decisions. My biggest gripe after driving 80 miles on it so far is it’ll slam on its brakes off and on when it comes across a pedestrian only cross walk that don’t have any people nearby or cross walk lights on and no cars or anything and treats it like a stop sign. I almost got rear ended doing it. Anyone else having these experiences?

I get it’s new and supposed to learn which is why I’m not 100% giving up on it. Still cool.


r/ModelY 1d ago

Looking for feedback

0 Upvotes

Deciding between Camry xle and Tesla model y premium. Looking for recommendations.
I currently work at Tesla and can charge my car onsite for free (I am assuming, must double check). I will get 0.99% APR on Tesla. Not sure about the APR for Camry. My current commute is about 36 miles round trip, and might go between 50-60 miles round trip when I recolate over next few months. Will mostly use the car for work on a daily basis and occasionally to drive around CA during holidays or weekends.

Not sure about insurance rates for both the vehicles.

Thinking for getting the car between Aug-Nov (if I decide to go with Tesla, I want to wait until CA govt. starts the EV rebate program).

Any inputs are appreciated. Posting this in both camry and model y reddits to get a better feedback.


r/ModelY 1d ago

Question Got a two week window for my MYP! What to expect?

1 Upvotes

I placed an order on Saturday for a blue and white MY premium AWD. just got a two week delivery window that starts on Sunday. However, I don’t have a VIN assigned yet.

How accurate is the two week window and should I expect a VIN before or during the window?


r/ModelY 1d ago

Cracked MYP Rim

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Anyone cracked their rim like this? I do not remember hitting a pothole at all, and surely would have. Went into a business and had no air pressure warning, came out two hours later and it said my PSI was 33. Took it to Discount thinking I had run over a nail and that was causing the slow leak…just had to be this.

Is this repairable, or is it just a shed some tears as I type my CC into a website while buying a single rear wheel?


r/ModelY 2d ago

Official Tesla 2026 Summer Update Announced

Thumbnail x.com
22 Upvotes

What's your favorite feature that's coming?


r/ModelY 2d ago

Question Matte Black PPF or Stealth PPF?

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

Need some help…. Picking up my Quicksilver 26 MYP Thursday and heading right to body shop for full wrap. Unsure on what to do. Originally wanted Matte Black PPF wrap, but my buddy said it’s going to be hard to clean and over time won’t look as good due to fading and maintaining…. Hmmmm

He suggested doing the stealth ppf on the quicksilver. Would love thoughts on longevity and maintaining… I’m really sold on matte black PPF and would love opinions or thoughts. Any thoughts would be helpful or if anyone has had experience with either.