Dear r/IsleOfMan,
I've seen a bunch of Facebook posts where folks seem to be pretty agitated about a (proposed) wind farm off the Island. Without all of the context, I'm having a hard time trying to tease out what the positions and precise objections are.
I think I've got the following, but would appreciate some additional local insight to understand it better.
In the "Against" camp, you have a couple of different positions, namely:
1) NIMBYs (Not in my back yard) - aesthetic injury to the area, could also include "noise" (I don't know how loud they are, and whether the sound would travel).
2) Ecological concerns - damage to the sea-bed, potential pollutions (from breakages/repairs).
3) Economics - the "deal" itself, that is the lease money isn't "enough"
In the "For" camp, I could only see comments pointing out that renewables are the "future", and so these folks are also in the "Ecological concerns" bucket, but on the other side.
Am I missing any relevant positions?
Also, I have a few questions - for the "Against" group, what is inherently wrong with diversifying away from fossil fuels? I would have thought that less dependence on imported oil/gas/fuel would be net positive for the island?
Is the economic deal really that bad, and if so, why are the folks in the "For" camp not raising this as an issue? Bad economics would be bad for everyone on the island, not just those opposed.
Lastly, how big of a deal is this? It is hard to calibrate something based on excited posts on social media - I'd love to hear the perspectives of others to be able to form an informed opinion.