Hi all,
I joined the mod team a month ago because I want to help make this a great place for IT managers to chat. In that time, we've added several rules to help cut down on bots and spam. I hope that this sub is feeling less like an AI sales funnel to you now. Yes, there is still more to do and we haven't done more yet because we need to have a chat as a sub. So lets talk!
Obviously, this sub became inundated with marketing, astroturfing, AI slop, and other off-topic content. While the mod team has done a lot to bring that down recently, I think that we should go even further. We're removing something like 25 things a day right now through automod rules, botbouncer, being in the sub, reports from users (thank you everyone who is reporting content!), etc. Going further, I'd suggest that we even say that r/sysadmin topics should be off-topic in this sub and reserve this sub specifically for IT manager talk amongst IT managers. Posts like seeking devops job would be against the rules if that rule I suggest is instituted.
Personally, I'd be happier with 3 high quality posts in a single week that are good discussions for an IT manager than 20 posts throughout the week with little value for most IT managers. I'm half tempted to state that if OP doesn't reply to at least 2-3 comments in a thread, then users should report it so that automod will remove it. Otherwise we get stuff like this account posting to screenshots problem.
However, I know that there are people here that like seeing new stuff that may actually be useful. I'm thinking of instituting an auto-post called "Marketing Monday" and tell all advertisers, promoters, opportunities, new consulting companies, and other similar stuff to go make a comment in that thread. It would allow us to have a nice clean line between the sub at large and this space for seeing new stuff. Posts like NIDS Selection for FI is a perfect example of the stuff that should be a comment in the marketing monday thread instead of its own post.
But what about all the posts that are more like r/AskITManagers instead of r/ITManagers where the user isn't creating a quality IT discussion and are just hoping to get all the wizards here to impart knowledge? Perfect example is How long after interview Should we allow that? I'm thinking no as well. Cut it way back and focus on our core theme of IT managers discussing IT management topics.
That was a lot, I know. Do you like what I'm talking about doing? Am I going overboard? Is the sub in a good spot in your mind now and should be left how it is? Maybe more in the middle between keep things as they are and massively prune? Do you have other ideas that we mods should consider?
TL;DR: Please report posts on the sub that you don't like. It doesn't take many reports to auto-remove them. And we mods will see them too to get a better idea of what to not allow in this sub.
Thanks all,
-Szeraax