Spoiler alert! Don’t read this if you haven’t seen the movie. I would recommend you watch it before you read my review. This is my opinion, if you don’t agree with it that’s fine, and would like to hear why you disagree with the following points.
I wish I could say this was a good movie and a fitting ending to the story of Nick and Charlie. However, I don’t think this movie contributed anything to the storyline or characters.
First, the interactions with the side-characters and Nick/Charlie:
How I see it, it’s mostly a send-off for every character. Monologue on top of monologue or one sided conversations with either Charlie or Nick. It feels forced. I get that this movie was on a budget. But the monologues don’t contribute anything. For example, the monologue in the end where Tao talks to Nick. In the book they talk about how their friendship has grown over time. Now, it’s just Tao who talks. He could’ve told anybody that monologue. It would’ve had the same message. Nick was not a contributing factor in that whole conversation.
Secondly, the whole pride scene:
I cringed. The whole thing felt so forced, no emotion whatsoever. You would think that when you’re marching for human rights, there would be more passion. Also, 2 chants would’ve gotten the point across. It felt like 5 minutes of cringe, emotionless chanting. Hardest scene to watch by far! Which is disappointing because this could’ve been so empowering. To stand up for trans rights is so important, and it didn’t feel that way.
Thirdly, Nick’s character:
What happened? The Nick we know from season one, has been nothing but masks? Don’t get me wrong, I’m not shaming the trauma or the insecurity. But it’s like he’s lost his entire way of coping. He used to talk about his emotions, about his thoughts, especially with his mom. But he bottles everything up now and has no conversation with his mom, with no explanation as to why. It doesn’t feel right to me. I don’t what else to say. It feels like they messed up Nick’s character. Everything that he was and that I’ve come to know just disappeared in the movie, which was disappointing to say the least.
Fourthly, the breakup(?) scene and the get-back-together scene:
Maybe this is a hot take, but I think Nick was mostly if not fully responsible for the breakup. Charlie said that maybe some space would be better for them. And Nick assumes Charlie wants to breakup. I get that he was not in a great headspace to begin with. But he didn’t communicate anything to Charlie. Or his mother? Which differs a lot from the books. He assumes it’s best for Charlie, that he’s too much. Listen, i feel for this moment. I myself can resonate with these thoughts and feelings of failure. And of course, he’s a teenager. But the way he just leaves? They don’t talk for what feels like a week or more? The time-skips were very confusing to be honest. For me, it comes down to responsibility. Nick initiated the break, he didn’t talk to anyone about what was going on and let his fears/insecurities lead his actions. He should’ve reached out, in my opinion. But I get that he probably felt like Charlie deserved better. Anyways, then the scene where they get back together. I would’ve expected a conversation about the things that were said, assumed and done by both of them (especially Nick, but Charlie too). How are they going to move forward? But no, it’s “I missed you” “I love you”. At least it felt like that to me. Which is weird, because Nick’s mom had a monologue scene right before this about how love is a choice. It doesn’t automatically mean that it’s going to work out. It’s something you choose to work for. But they turned it to “We’re Nick and Charlie. We’re different than other relationships.” Not the message you want to send to teenagers right? That conflict should not be talked about as long as you love each other?
Lastly:
I miss Olivia Colman. I get why she couldn’t be part of the movie, but I missed her.
To conclude:
I will never watch this again. My tzatziki dip made the experience better. I don’t know what I would’ve done without it.
The first 3 seasons are amazing and I will cherish them forever.
No movie would’ve been better than this movie.