r/Fantasy 16d ago

Book Club r/Fantasy July Megathread and Book Club hub. Get your links here!

23 Upvotes

This is the Monthly Megathread for July 2026. It's where the mod team links important things. It will always be stickied at the top of the subreddit. Please regularly check here for things like official movie and TV discussions, book club news, important subreddit announcements, etc.

Last month's book club hub can be found here.

Important Links

New Here? Have a look at:

You might also be interested in our yearly BOOK BINGO reading challenge.

Special Threads & Megathreads:

Recurring Threads:

Book Club Hub - Book Clubs and Read-alongs

Goodreads Book of the Month: Letters from a Shipwreck in the Sea of Suns & Moons by Raymond St. Elmo

Run by u/fanny_bertram u/RAAAImmaSunGod u/PlantLady32

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - July 14th
  • Final Discussion - July 27th

Feminism in Fantasy: The Last Contract of Isako by Fonda Lee

Run by u/xenizondich23u/Nineteen_Adzeu/g_annu/Moonlitgrey

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - July 15th
  • Final Discussion - July 29th

New Voices: Sublimation by Isabel J. Kim

Run by u/HeLiBeBu/cubansombrerou/ullsi u/undeadgoblin

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - July 13th
  • Final Discussion - July 27th

HEA: The Reanimator's Heart by Kara Jorgensen

Run by u/tiniestspoonu/xenizondich23 , u/orangewombat

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - July 16th
  • Final Discussion - July 30th

Beyond Binaries: Returns in August with The Dawnhounds by Sascha Stromach

Run by u/xenizondich23u/eregis

Short Fiction Book Club: On a break until the end of the Hugo Readalong (see below)

Run by u/tarvolonu/Nineteen_Adzeu/Jos_V

Readalong of The Magnus Archives:

Hosted by u/improperly_paranoid u/sharadereads u/Dianthaa

Hugo Readalong


r/Fantasy Apr 01 '26

Bingo OFFICIAL r/Fantasy 2026 Book Bingo Challenge!

649 Upvotes

WELCOME TO BINGO 2026!

It's a reading challenge, a reading party, a reading marathon, and YOU are invited!

r/Fantasy Book Bingo is a yearly reading challenge within our community. Its one-year mission: to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new authors and books, to boldly go where few readers have gone before. 

The core of this challenge is encouraging readers to step out of their comfort zones, discover amazing new reads, and motivate everyone to keep up on their reading throughout the year.

You can find all our past challenges at our official Bingo wiki page for the sub.

RULES:

Time Period and Prize

  • 2026 Bingo Period lasts from April 1st 2026 - March 31st 2027.
  • You will be able to turn in your 2026 card in the Official Turn In Post, which will be posted in mid-March 2027. Only submissions through the Google Forms link in the official post will count.
  • 'Reading Champion' flair will be assigned to anyone who completes the entire card by the end of the challenge. If you already have this flair, you will receive a roman numeral after 'Reading Champion' indicating the number of times you completed Bingo. These take a few months to dole out, so please be patient.

Repeats and Rereads

  • You can’t use the same book more than once on the card. One square = one book.
  • You may not repeat an author on the card unless a square specifies otherwise. EXCEPTION: you may read a full book from an author for one square and a single short story from the same author for the Five Short Stories square. If you read a fully collection from the author for Five Short Stories Hard Mode though, you cannot reuse the author for another square.
  • Only ONE square can be a re-read. All other books must be first-time reads. The point of Bingo is to explore new grounds, so get out there and explore books you haven't read before.

Substitutions

  • You may substitute ONE square from the 2026 card with a square from a previous r/Fantasy bingo card if you wish to. Previous squares can be found via the Bingo wiki page.
  • You may NOT reuse a square that duplicates a square already on this card (e.g.: you cannot have two "Book Club" squares).
  • You may NOT reuse the "Free Space" square from Bingo 2015.
  • You may NOT reuse the “Not a Book” square from Bingo 2025.
  • You may NOT reuse the “Recycle a Bingo Square” square from Bingo 2025.

Upping the Difficulty

  • HARD MODE: For an added challenge, you can choose to do 'Hard Mode' which is the square with something added just to make it a little more difficult. You can do one, some, none, or all squares on 'Hard Mode' -- whatever you want, it's up to you! There are no additional prizes for completing Hard Modes, it's purely a self-driven challenge for those who want to do it.
  • HERO MODE: Review EVERY book that you read for bingo. You don't have to review it here on r/Fantasy. It can be on Goodreads, Amazon, your personal blog, some other review site, wherever! Leave a review, not just ratings, even if it's just a few lines of thoughts, that counts. As with Hard Mode there is no special prize for hero mode, just the satisfaction of a job well done.

This is not a hard rule, but I would encourage everyone to post about what you're reading, progress, etc., in at least one of the official r/Fantasy monthly book discussion threads that post on the 30th of each month (except February, where it posts on the 28th). Let us know what you think of the books you're reading! The monthly threads are also a goldmine for finding new reading material.

And now presenting, the Bingo 2026 Card and Squares!

First Row Across:

  1. Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist: Story features a trans or nonbinary protagonist. This protagonist must NOT be an alien or robot. HARD MODE: Set in a pre-modern time period.
  2. Judge a Book By Its Title: Read a book based on the title. This can be a title so epic you had to pick it up or so weird and off-putting that you needed to know why it was called this. HARD MODE: Dive in without reading the blurb or any summaries.
  3. Translated: Story has been translated from a language you don’t read or speak. HARD MODE: First translated into your language within the last 5 years.
  4. Small Press or Self Published: Read a book published by a small press (NOT a Big 5 publisher or Bloomsbury) or self-published. If a formerly self-published book gets picked up by a publisher, you can only count it for this square if you read it before it was traditionally published. HARD MODE: The book has under 100 ratings on Goodreads OR is by an author from a marginalized group.
  5. Unusual Transportation: Story includes a surprising method of moving from place to place. By “unusual” we mean that it is out of the ordinary in real life AND uncommon to the book’s broader genre. This can include a highly unique take on a genre staple (spaceships with FTL wouldn’t normally count but the Infinite Improbability Drive from Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy would) or be a completely original mode of transit (autoducks in The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy). HARD MODE: Transportation is NOT combustion-powered or steam-powered. If the power source is not stated, use your best judgment. A story likely won’t specify that cars are combustion-powered and horses aren’t, but a reasonable person would assume those things to be true if they’re not stated. Likewise, in a steampunk setting, the chances are good that the transport is steam-powered.

Second Row Across

  1. The Afterlife: Story deals with the realm of the dead. This could be communicating with the dead, spirits transferring over, or being set in the afterlife itself. HARD MODE: The afterlife does NOT depict a “Good Place” vs “Bad Place” dichotomy.

  2. Game Changer: Story features a game or competition. HARD MODE: The protagonist bends or breaks the rules in some way.

  3. Vacation Spot: Story takes place somewhere you’d want to visit (either fictional or non-fictional). This is subjective, as everyone has different tastes. A cozy cottage at the edge of the sea, a mansion in the fantasy Alps, a cruise ship in the stars - anything can count, as long as you think you would enjoy visiting this world. HARD MODE: No hard mode. You deserve a break.

  4. Five Short Stories: Read any 5 speculative fiction short stories. HARD MODE: Read an entire anthology or collection (must contain at least 5 stories).

10.Older Protagonist: Story features a main character who is at least 50 years old. HARD MODE: The protagonist does NOT have exceptional longevity or immortality (e.g. not an elf, dwarf, vampire, god, etc.).

Third Row Across

  1. Duology Part 1: Read the first book in a duology. HARD MODE: By an author you haven’t read before.

  2. r/Fantasy Book Club or Readalong Book: Tackle any past or active r/Fantasy book clubs OR past or active r/Fantasy readalongs. See our full list of book clubs here. NOTE: All of the current book club info can also be found on our Goodreads page. Every book added to our Goodreads shelf or on this Google Sheet counts for this square. You can see our past readalongs here. HARD MODE: Partake in a current selection of either a book club or readalong and participate in the discussion.

  3. Published in 2026: Read a book published for the first time in 2026 (no reprints or new editions). HARD MODE: It's the author's first published novel.

  4. Explorers and Rangers: Story features an explorer (a character who travels to and investigates an unfamiliar region) or a ranger (a wilderness or forest-oriented warrior frequently specializing in things like stealth, bows, tracking, and other hunting-related skills). HARD MODE: The explorer or ranger has an animal companion.

  5. Duology Part 2: Read the second book in a duology. For this square, you ARE allowed to read the same author you used for Duology Part 1 without violating the no-repeat author rule. HARD MODE: Finish a different duology than you started for the Duology Part 1 square.

Fourth Row Across

  1. One-Word Title: Story has a one-word title. HARD MODE: Title is NOT a proper noun (no names of people or places)!

  2. Non-Human Protagonist: Story features a main character who is NOT human. HARD MODE: There are no human POVs in the story.

  3. Middle Grade: Read a middle grade book (intended for readers aged 8-12). See this Wikipedia page for additional information on Middle Grade fiction. HARD MODE: The author is entirely new to you.

  4. First Contact: Story prominently features interspecies or interracial meeting for the first time. HARD MODE: Non-violent first contact.

  5. Murder Mystery: Main plot of the story focuses on solving a murder. HARD MODE: The main character is NOT a detective or private investigator.

Fifth Row Across

  1. Cat Squasher: Read a book over 500 pages in length. An omnibus book (multiple novels in one volume) doesn't count for this. HARD MODE: Over 900 pages.

  2. Feast Your Eyes on This: Food or a meal is significant to the story’s plot. HARD MODE: Attempt making a dish from the story for yourself. We understand faithful replication may be impossible for any number of reasons (the ingredients may be fictional, unobtainable, or too expensive). Just get as close as you reasonably can.

  3. Published in the 70s: Read a book that was first published any time between 1970 and 1979. HARD MODE: Written by a woman.

  4. Politics and Court Intrigue: Politics are central to the story’s plot. This covers everything from royalty, elections, and wars, to smaller local politics. HARD MODE: There is a prominent focus on politics at a city level or lower.

  5. Author of Color: Story written by a person of color. HARD MODE: Author does NOT live in the U.S., the U.K., Canada, Australia, or New Zealand.

FAQs

What Counts?

  • Can I read non-speculative fiction books for this challenge? Not unless the square says so specifically. As a speculative fiction sub, we expect all books to be spec fic (fantasy, sci fi, horror, etc.). If you aren't sure what counts, see the next FAQ bullet point.
  • Does ‘X’ book count for ‘Y’ square? Bingo is mostly to challenge yourself and your own reading habit. If you are wondering if something counts or not for a square, ask yourself if you feel confident it should count. You don't need to overthink it. If you aren't confident, you can ask around. If no one else is confident, it's much easier to look for recommendations people are confident will count instead. If you still have questions, free to ask here or in our Daily Simple Questions threads. Either way, we'll get you your answers.
  • If a self-published book is picked up by a publisher, does it still count as self-published? Sadly, no. If you read it while it was still solely self-published, then it counts. But once a publisher releases it, it no longer counts.
  • Are we allowed to read books in other languages for the squares? Absolutely!

Does it have to be a novel specifically?

  • You can read or listen to any narrative fiction for a square so long as it is at least novella length. This includes short story collections/anthologies, web novels, graphic novels, manga, webtoons, fan fiction, audiobooks, audio dramas, and more.
  • If your chosen medium is not roughly novella length, you can also read/listen to multiple entries of the same type (e.g. issues of a comic book or episodes of a podcast) to count it as novella length. Novellas are roughly equivalent to 70-100 print pages or 3-4 hours of audio.

Timeline

  • Do I have to start the book from 1st of April 2026 or only finish it from then? If the book you've started is less than 50% complete when April 1st hits, you can count it if you finish it after the 1st.

I don't like X square, why don't you get rid of it or change it?

  • This depends on what you don't like about the square. Accessibility or cultural issues? We want to fix those! The square seems difficult? Sorry, that's likely the intent of the square. Remember, Bingo is a challenge and there are always a few squares every year that are intended to push participants out of their comfort zone.

Help! I still have questions!

Resources:

If anyone makes any resources be sure to ping me in the thread and let me know so I can add them here, thanks!

Thank You, r/Fantasy!

A huge thank you to:

  • the community here for continuing to support this challenge. We couldn't do this without you!
  • the users who take extra time to make resources for the challenge (including Bingo cards, tracking spreadsheets, etc), answered Bingo-related questions, made book recommendations, and made suggestions for Bingo squares--you guys rock!!
  • the folks that run the various r/Fantasy book clubs and readalongs, you're awesome!
  • the other mods who help me behind the scenes, love you all!

Last but not least, thanks to everyone participating! Have fun and good luck!


r/Fantasy 7h ago

People often talk about favorite opening lines in books, but what’s your favorite closing line or sentence in a fantasy novel? Spoiler

244 Upvotes

Mine is from piranesi "Beauty of the house is immeasurable; it's kindness infinite"


r/Fantasy 3h ago

Where are all the paladin books?

64 Upvotes

Is anyone else interested in books about paladins? I can't seem to find any.

  • Saint of steel series by kingfisher - this is close, but they're paladins of a dead god.
  • Deed of paksenarrion - this is about someone becoming a paladin, not being one
  • Paladin of souls - this is much more about a priest or spiritualist than what i consider a paladin
  • Michael from the Dresden files would qualify, but obviously he's not the main character.
  • Priest by matt colville has an awesome order of paladins, but again not the focus

It seems to me like there's obviously space for some books about a paladin (or even an order of them) that fight for their god to vanquish evil or at least an opposing god. Where are they?


r/Fantasy 35m ago

Ancient Greece inspired fantasy?

Upvotes

Hi all, I, like everyone and their mothers, have just watched Nolan's Odyssey adaptation and now I'm in the mood for Ancient Greece-inspired fantasy. Either actually set in Ancient Greece or in a setting inspired by Ancient Greece. Not looking for myth retellings, which I know will narrow it down quite a bit.

Examples of the kind of books I'm looking for are the Queen's Thief novels and AJ Demas' novels.


r/Fantasy 6h ago

Is it just me, or is The Licanius Trilogy extremely confusing?

32 Upvotes

I’ve just started reading the third book, The Light of All That Falls, after finishing the first two books - The Shadow of What Was Lost and An Echo of Things to Come.

While reading the recap at the beginning of the third book, I realised that I had completely missed or forgotten so many important details from the first two books. Now I’m reading the recap and thinking, “Wait, when did this happen?”

I usually enjoy complex fantasy, but I found The Licanius Trilogy really confusing at times. The plot, timelines, characters and all the twists can be difficult to keep track of.

I’ve also read the first two books of Islington’s The Hierarchy series, and I honestly think they are better written. Maybe because The Licanius Trilogy was his first series, he was still figuring out how to handle and organise so many details. It feels like his writing and storytelling improved a lot in The Hierarchy.

So, is it just me being dumb, or did anyone else find the first two books confusing as well?


r/Fantasy 7h ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions Thread - July 22, 2026

40 Upvotes

Welcome to the daily recommendation requests and simple questions thread, now 1025.83% more adorable than ever before!

Stickied/highlight slots are limited, so please remember to like and subscribe upvote this thread for visibility on the subreddit <3

——

This thread is to be used for recommendation requests or simple questions that are small/general enough that they won’t spark a full thread of discussion.

Check out r/Fantasy's 2026 Book Bingo Card here!

As usual, first have a look at the sidebar in case what you're after is there. The r/Fantasy wiki contains links to many community resources, including "best of" lists, flowcharts, the LGTBQ+ database, and more. If you need some help figuring out what you want, think about including some of the information below:

  • Books you’ve liked or disliked
  • Traits like prose, characters, or settings you most enjoy
  • Series vs. standalone preference
  • Tone preference (lighthearted, grimdark, etc)
  • Complexity/depth level

Be sure to check out responses to other users' requests in the thread, as you may find plenty of ideas there as well. Happy reading, and may your TBR grow ever higher!

——

tiny image link to make the preview show up correctly

art credit: special thanks to our artist, Himmis commissions, who we commissioned to create this gorgeous piece of art for us with practically no direction other than "cozy, magical, bookish, and maybe a gryphon???" We absolutely love it, and we hope you do too.


r/Fantasy 1h ago

Fantasy with Middle Eastern setting like in Arabian Nights

Upvotes

I loved the stories from One Thousand and One Nights and the Aladdin movie. Now I want to read more books with a similar setting. Djinns, flying carpets, desert nights.

Here are some books I really enjoyed:

  • Rebel of the Sands by Alwyn Hamilton
  • Sands of Arawiya by Hafsah Faizal
  • The Daevabad Trilogy by S.A. Chakraborty
  • The Sandsea Trilogy by Chelsea Abdullah
  • This Woven Kingdom by Tahareh Mafi
  • The Wrath & the Dawn by Renee Ahdieh

The most important thing is the setting. It can have political intrigues like City of Brass or be more adventurous like Rebel of the Sands. It can be YA or high fantasy. Lighthearted or very dark. With or without romance. High or low magic. New series or old, obscure novels. Basically everything that captures the feeling of 1001 Nights.

What books can you recommend?


r/Fantasy 17h ago

Is there a book that comes very close to being the literary equivalent of Dark Souls?

142 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering what fantasy books feel the most “Soulslike.” Not necessarily books that directly inspired the games (though those are welcome too), but books that capture a very similar atmosphere, vibe, aesthetic and feeling. I’m caught up with Berserk for manga which I know influenced Dark Souls a lot, but is there any for novels too? So far I have also consistently heard of Book of the New Sun which is in my list of books to read


r/Fantasy 6h ago

Review Silverblood Promise was an absolute blast

15 Upvotes

Picked this up off a recent booktuber recommendation, and decided to give it a shot between the To Green Angel Tower books, and it turned out to be a perfect choice.

The book follows Lukan Gardova, the son of a formerly great and wealthy house, brought to ruin in part because of Lukan accidentally killing a prince during a duel. Lukan is a bit of an idiot, quick to mouth off at the worst times, but is still a genuinely solid character. When his father is murdered, Lukan is sent to the merchant city of Saphrona to hunt down the mysterious Zandrosa - though he has no clue who or what that is. In his search, Lukan gets pulled into a great conspiracy, and has to manage to save himself as well as some friends made along the way.

The city of Saphrona is fantastic and well realized, full of both barbaric customs of the past and idealistic progression towards a better future. Through his journey, Lukan will see prisoners put up against horrific monsters, break into prisons that nobody escapes from, and contend with monsters thought to be fantasy.

He quickly meets the young pickpocket Flea, and their budding friendship is easily my favorite part of the book. The two made me laugh constantly, and as the story goes on and the stakes get higher, their genuine concern for one another lent the book a lot of emotional weight.

I will say for a book I see touted as a swashbuckling adventure, with a hero touted for his skill with the sword, there wasn't a whole lot of actual sword fighting, or honestly fighting in general, but the adventure was there in spades, and I was more than satisfied and fully intend to read book two when I get a chance.

For now, I'm taking a quick diversion into another Cradle book before I return to finish Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn.


r/Fantasy 4h ago

Review Novella Readathon #22: The Story of Gumluck the Wizard by Adam Rex

10 Upvotes

As an English teacher who mostly works with 6th graders, I quite like Middle Grade Fantasy and think that they get overlooked and undervalued in the genre fiction world. However, novellas aren’t particularly common in the middle grade space, which made it hard to find a good fit if I truly wanted to have a novella themed r/fantasy bingo card, which requires a middle grade book this year. I decided to go with something a bit sillier and younger than I’d normally read in this space; Gumluck is more targeted at 8-9 year-olds than 11-12, and I think it would probably make a great bedtime storybook for kids even younger than 8.

Read If Looking For: sassy ravens, technically compliant wishes, telling the truth isn’t always the right move 

Avoid If You Dislike: goofiness, egregious misunderstandings, lovable loners 

Does it Bingo?  The Afterlife (HM), Middle Grade, Also this one probably fits older protagonist? Gumluck implies he was significantly older at one point but uses magic to keep himself in a child’s body.

I don't think it fits nonhuman protagonist; our narrator is the raven, but Gumluck is the protagonist.

To the other reviews in this readathon, see my announcement post.

Elevator Pitch:
Gumluck is the Very Small Wizard who Lives in a Very Big Hill. The villagers ask him for help, but never say hello or thank you. Gumluck accidentally knocks over the raven Helvetica’s nest, sparking the start of a long friendship and many silly adventures for the series to follow. In this book, Gumluck wants to become the Harvest Hero, a prize given to the most helpful villager - who conveniently has been the crown prince for the past two decades. However, he doesn't realize the villagers look down on him, but he will press on to try and help as many people as he possibly can.

What Worked for Me
 This book had enough humor in it that I enjoyed my time with Gumluck. At first the over-the-top characters and bumbling attitudes annoyed me. However, the farcical vibes were tempered by the dry humor of Helvetica. Without her as our narrator, I think I would have strongly disliked this book. As it stands, she provides good tonal breaks with her dry wit and lovable grumpiness. Is she kind of a stereotypical character? Yes, she is. But I'm a sucker for people who point out the obvious and have no time of other people's quiet niceties, so her bluntness really endeared me to her. She also served as a good mouthpiece to get at various themes for kids who developmentally are still working on inference and abstract concepts.

I also feel like this is a book that will be great for developmentally typical kids in the 3rd grade range. Yes, some people were reading Wheel of Time at that age, but Gumluck is a much more appropriate book for the average kid that age into fantasy. There’s conflict without it being violent. There’s some social skills instruction without it feeling over explained. It's not going to give them nightmares or close enough to reality for them to start overlapping the two. The book has lots of cute illustrations that keep developing readers interest as they bridge into chapter books. Also Helvetica (whom I love dearly), again makes for a great narrator during a read aloud, since gives the story the vibe of an oral tale already, making it a great fit for parents and kids still learning to read.

What Didn’t Work for Me
The biggest strike against this book is that I’m not the target audience for it. It was enjoyable enough, but not one that is going to appeal more broadly to adult audiences or kids who  feel they’ve outgrown ‘books for little kids’. It’s got less edge to it than a Disney Movie, and that tone would have grated on me had I chosen to pick up the sequel. I won't buy a copy for my classroom, as even my low readers are going to bounce off this pretty hard. I will, however, consider giving it as a gift to my friends who are new parents.

Conclusion: most adults won’t enjoy this unless they’re reading it with their kids. However, it’s the type of story I’d have wanted my mom to read to me

Novella Bingo Card
I plan on having a novella-themed bingo card this year. I originally mood read and slotted in choices, but at this point I'm close enough that I can see the light at the end of the tunnel. I still won't read something just for the bingo card (other than the middle grade square), but I can taste a finished card! Here's where I stand so far 


r/Fantasy 1d ago

What's the best "slow reveal" you've read in adult fantasy? Not the biggest twist, but the moment you realised the story was much larger than you first thought. What made it work?

1.0k Upvotes

I'm not looking for the biggest plot twist or surprise ending.

I'm thinking about those moments where you suddenly realise the world, history, or conflict is much bigger than you first believed, but in hindsight all the clues were there if you knew where to look and what you were looking at.

Which book did this best for you?

More importantly, what made it satisfying rather than feeling like it came out of nowhere?


r/Fantasy 20h ago

It appears Glen Cook finally has a deal for the next GARRETT, P.I. book: LAST METAL ROMANCE

69 Upvotes

Cook mentioned Last Metal Romance (and a potential second new Garrett novel, Deadly Diamond Daydreams) in that bombshell April 2024 interview with Black Gate that also announced the whole Pitiless Rain/Orphans' Tale Black Company sequel series, though at the time there wasn't any progress on the horizon and he seemed pretty frustrated with the process.

But good news! A deal was announced on Publishers Marketplace in early July:

Glen Cook's LAST METAL ROMANCE, the latest installment in the author's Garrett, P. I. fantasy-noir series, to Shahid Mahmud at Arc Manor, in a nice deal, for publication in May 2027, by Russell Galen at Scovil Galen Ghosh Literary Agency (world).

Arc Manor Publishing also featured it as a forthcoming title in their Spring 2026 catalog, with a logline:

Garrett P.I. has seen it all, but then a routine job spirals into a deadly conspiracy. As a violent sect rises and the city teeters on collapse, Garrett must uncover why everyone wants this mysterious girl dead—before politics and bloodshed tear the city apart.

Super exciting for Cook fans. It's been over a decade since the last Garrett book!


r/Fantasy 1h ago

The Arthurian Age Series by Sean Poage, worth reading?

Upvotes

as the name implies, I’ve come across this series in my local bookstore and it looks cool, was wondering if this is worth picking up and what other people think of it.


r/Fantasy 23h ago

Review One Mike to Read Them All: “The Eye of Leviathan” by M.A. Carrick

52 Upvotes

This second collaboration of Marie Brennan and Alyc Helms (under the combined pen name of M.A. Carrick) is very different from their absolutely fantastic Rook & Rose trilogy. That one I think of as Scott Lynch + Zorro + a metric ton of flirtations and sexual tension. This is much darker, and much more serious: it’s set in a reimagined late 16th/early 17th century Spain, where not only are the Spanish colonizing the New World, they are also colonizing the Sea Beyond: the faerie seas one can reach by sailing through the Straight of Gibraltar Pillars of Hercules under the right astrological conditions (with a few other restrictions as well).

The story begins with a Spanish noblewoman, having just given birth to (yet another) daughter, confiding in her friend, a tree spirit. Her husband has threatened to kill the child if it was another girl, and not the son he wants. The tree spirit offers a suggestion: leave the girl with the faerie grove, unbaptized, and the spirit of the tree can take the form of a boy child and take her place. The mother won’t get to raise her youngest daughter, but she’ll be safe; and the tree spirit will use his disguise to investigate the Spanish and learn how they’re subjugating his brethren from the Sea Beyond.

This is a story with two co-protagonists. First is the tree spirit, now a boy called Estevan making his way through Catholic Spain, trying to avoid drawing the ire of either his father or the ever-alert Inquisition (in this conception as watchful for fae influence as they are for insincere Muslim or Jewish converts or Protestant heretics). His goal is the royal Council of the Sea Beyond, overseeing the conquest of the fae, their baptism (or elimination), and the theft of their wealth & power - and the secrets behind how they’re doing it.

The other is the girl, who (how is unclear) made her way from the faerie grove into the company of the faeries of the Sea Beyond. She is known only as the Hungry Girl - the fae are immortal, and wherever she’s been they keep forgetting that mortals need to eat every single day. More than once even! She has heard many stories of the dreaded Conquistadors, with their strange ships made of dead trees and their weapons and armor of deadly iron. When she finally meets some Spaniards, she’s relieved they are merchants looking for trade, not conquest - and listens eagerly when their captain tells her that she needs to return to the mortal lands to get baptized, lest she burn in Hell for all eternity. That doesn’t sound good at all, so the Hungry Girl is very eager for this “baptism” thing.

My bet is that Alyc did the writing for the Hungry Girl, and Marie Estevan. I look forward to finding out if I’m right.

This is a pretty dark story all told. The European conquest of the Americas was absolutely brutal, and the actions of the Spanish in the Sea Beyond are on par with the real world history. And this is also the era shortly after the Reconquista, when both Muslims (who had ruled the Iberian peninsula) and Jews (who had been tolerated and flourished under Muslim rule) had to convert or die - and if they chose to convert, were persecuted by the Inquisition for generations after. None of that is glossed over.

I expected something great out of Brennan & Helms, and while this wasn’t what I was expecting, it is certainly something great. Very eager for #2.

Bingo categories: Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist - technically, because the nonbinary character is a tree spirit and the rules say “not an alien or a robot,” but is very much not in the spirit of the square. But if you’re going to count it it would be [Hard Mode]; Unusual Transportation [Hard Mode]; Older Protagonist; Duology Part 1; Published in 2026; Non-Human Protagonist; Cat Squasher; Politics and Court Intrigue

My blog


r/Fantasy 3h ago

Has anyone read Rachel Pollack's books?

1 Upvotes

I know her from Doom Patrol and the Tarot world, but recently learned she has multiple award-winning fantasy novels. Has anyone read them? Are they worth reading?


r/Fantasy 7h ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Writing Wednesday Thread - July 22, 2026

2 Upvotes

The weekly Writing Wednesday thread is the place to ask questions about writing. Wanna run an idea past someone? Looking for a beta reader? Have a question about publishing your first book? Need worldbuilding advice? This is the place for all those questions and more.

Self-promo rules still apply to authors' interactions on r/fantasy. Questions about writing advice that are posted as self posts outside of this thread will still be removed under our off-topic policy.


r/Fantasy 12h ago

Specific question about All This and More by Peng Shepard

4 Upvotes

I'm using an e-reader (not sure if that matters given this novel has branching choices)

I'm in a chapter called Serendipity. At the end of the chapter there is only choice. I didn't love that choice so I thought you could just turn to the next page, but that takes me to another chapter which doesn't make sense at all it jumps into the middle of a poker game and thus far there has been absolutely zero mention of poker. So is there only choice for this chapter?


r/Fantasy 1h ago

Looking for recs for fantasy that's out of the box, women, and POC.

Upvotes

I have a literature degree, I read a lot ( r/52book ) and I've read all the classics, all the usual stuff in fantasy and sci fi, plus a lot of horror. I adore GRRM, Abercrombie, Hobb, the usual suspects.

I've been branching out and trying to read more women and POC telling different kinds of stories. I recently finished *The Fifth Season* and really enjoyed it. I'm waiting on *Dark Age* from the library. I just DNFd *When the Moon Hatched* yesterday, about 3 hours in. My favorite from the last few years has been Cadwell Turnbull's Convergence trilogy. I have the first two books of Malazan and will read that eventually.

Also, I've seen lists that include Mark Lawrence's Broken Empire as top rated dark fantasy, but I dont recall seeing it recommended here. Is it worth reading?

TIA.


r/Fantasy 1d ago

AMA I’m J.R. Dawson, Hugo short story finalist, and my paperback comes out today! AMA!

Thumbnail jrdawsonwriter.com
63 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m J.R. Dawson, and I’m a Nebula, Hugo, and Sturgeon finalist for my short story, “Six People to Revise You”. My first book from Tor, THE FIRST BRIGHT THING, won two Golden Crown Awards. And today, THE LIGHTHOUSE AT THE EDGE OF THE WORLD is out in paperback from Tor!

I also teach at Drexel University’s MFA program and The Loft Literary Center. I’ve got more short stories in places like Uncanny, Reactor, F&SF, Lightspeed, and more.

I’m a dog mom, a bad cook, and a big fan of animation. AMA!


r/Fantasy 1d ago

Athlete Focused fantasy?

58 Upvotes

Most of the time in fantasy if there is a sport, we the readers, get introduced to it alongside the main character. I'm looking for the opposite, where the POV character is already well-versed in the sport, and doesn't pause the narrative to explain what's going on. I'm primarily intrested in books where we follow an athlete but it can be anyone who understands the sport.

Thanks in advance!


r/Fantasy 21h ago

Morally grey, unique pov and subplot romance books?

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone, im looking for fantasy book recommendations with:

- A morally grey or grimdark atmosphere

- A male protagonist (or predominantly male POV)

- A romance subplot that feels natural and meaningful, rather than being the main focus (but can be like 49% of the book lol)

- Strong worldbuilding, preferably in a medieval fantasy setting

Most of the books I've found with these elements were centered on female protagonists or female POVs. While I've enjoyed some of them, I'm hoping to find something I can relate to more through a male lead.

As a point of reference, one thing I really enjoyed in Baldur's Gate 3 was the dynamic with characters like Shadowheart: people who initially seem guarded, cynical, or morally ambiguous, but gradually reveal a more vulnerable side. I'd love to see a similar kind of character development and relationship in a fantasy novel.

Bonus points for complex characters. Political intrigue, and dark themes withoutbbeing relentlessly bleak.

Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated!

Also, i dont mind extreme violence, graphic content, explicit sexual content, or other mature themes, so feel free to recommend books without worrying about that.


r/Fantasy 23h ago

Towers

10 Upvotes

I absolutely loved The Blacktongue Thief and The Daughters’ War. I cant wait for The Thrice-Bound Fool! I’m really hoping Christopher Buehlman eventually publishes the card game Towers as a real, playable game. He replied to a post a year back, saying he has a prototype in the works and is playtesting.

Christopher Buehlman, if you're reading this, I would love to play a round with you!

Until then, I've been trying to recreate Towers at home. I’ve played around with the game mechanics and rules, but there are so many ambiguities that I don’t think the text alone answers them.

I put together a list of questions/possible rules gaps. I’d love to hear everyone’s thoughts and interpretations:

Gameplay

  • Do players take turns placing one card at a time, or can you place multiple cards at once?
  • Can Thief, Archer, and Death cards be played immediately as out-of-turn reactions?
  • Can the Queen be used as a reaction to the Traitor or does she draw it out?

Card Questions

Archer

  • Is the Archer the only offensive weapon in the game?
  • Does the Archer have a single use and then become dormant?

Archer / Sapper / Thief

  • Do these cards perform one action and then become inactive, or do they continue acting each turn until defeated?

Soldier

  • Is the Soldier basically a disposable shield?
  • Can it be played preemptively to block future attacks, or as a reaction?
  • Can a Soldier defend against a Sapper?

Sapper

  • If Sappers can only steal honey from a destroyed/downed Tower, why would anyone ever choose to silo honey inside a Tower?

Tower Silo Rules

  • A card hidden under a Tower is protected from Archers. If a Sapper destroys the Tower, the hidden card is revealed.
  • Can the player voluntarily reveal a siloed card?
  • If the card is never revealed, does it still count/bank somehow?
  • Can Death be banked by hiding in a silo, from a tourney round to the war round? How else does death get banked without being revealed?

Feeding / Resource Timing

  • Can I play Masters together with their required honey/coin, or do I need to spend a turn placing resources first? Can I play resources after the master?
  • Do resources remain on the table and apply to any future Master played?

I’m sure some of this may have obvious answers but I’m curious how everyone else interpreted the rules.

Would love to hear your house rules or any clarifications you’ve come up with!

Clink-clink


r/Fantasy 1d ago

Review 31 Novellas in 31 Days: The Practice, The Horizon, and The Chain by Sofia Samatar

32 Upvotes

Sofia Samatar has been on my reading list for a long time. I always figured I’d start with The Winged Histories, but this novella kept getting rave reviews, and I love a school/academia setting. I knew this story dealt with class displacement from the chatter, but I wasn’t prepared for how sharply Samatar wields the pen … or perhaps keyboard. This is yet another author that I have now committed to reading more of; I wanted this project to lessen my TBR, but it has in fact done the exact opposite. 

Read If Looking For: thematically dense stories, nuanced yet archetypical characters, the pointlessness of meetings and committees

Avoid If Looking For: plot heavy books, tidy endings, school settings featuring classroom scenes, happy vibes

Does it Bingo? Judge a Book by its Title, Book Club (2025 Hugo Readalong), and Author of Color

To the other reviews in this readathon, see my announcement post.

Elevator Pitch:
The Fleet travels from mining site to mining site, remaining for generations before making a long journey to a new source of resources. The boy is one of the Chained, laboring in the darkness beneath, and the professor is one of the ankleted, a sort of middle working class. Some of her friends don’t bear any fetters at all. The professor brings the boy out of the darkness, 'liberating' him to her class and installing him as a student at her university. It does not go as smoothly as she'd like. As the two grapple with the chains they bear, they both realize they have much more to learn.

This is a bad description for the book, and I offer my apologies

What Worked for Me
This novella is not subtle about its themes, but neither is it preachy or didactic. I think Samatar does a great job of layering meaning into the story, asking the reader to consider the situations of the characters, but she never quite steps out of the story to speak directly to the reader. At its most obvious is the focus on class differences. Notably, the professor sees herself as having saved the boy. He perceives himself as having lost all connections to his culture and his people, even though his physical situation is better than as a slave-laborer below. He is expected to be grateful, but he finds himself unmoored because the Chained built a cultural identity and community; the boy has become an island. Meanwhile the professor ends up reckoning with her own place in the system, passed over for papers and promotions and fighting for any scraps of recognition from the unfettered elite. However, her position of power over another group gives her a sense of artificial freedom. This freedom becomes threatened as she realizes the inadequacy of her own 'help,' but pushing further goes beyond the bounds of what has been deemed acceptable by those above her in the hierarchy. There are some layers introduced early that get peeled back beautifully during the second half of the novella, a really excellent use of foreshadowing. 

The earliest, and most obvious, tell to get the reader thinking, is that the Chained and those with indigo anklets never get named. Only those without any fetters at all receive names in this book, a not-so-subtle nod to whom society sees as human, and who is a faceless cog in the machine. This comes to a head beautifully when Gil, the professor’s coworker, who considers her a dear friend, unleashes an angry tirade that shows that even his own support and bonding with the professor end when she does not act in accordance with his wishes. It is only in this moment that the professor’s relationship with the boy begins to truly shift to something akin to equals. Until she acknowledges her own enslavement, she cannot see how she enslaves others. 

In a really phenomenal interview (you should go read it alongside this Novella. I sort of wish I’d read it before, to be honest), Samatar talks about how this book was born from the murder of George Flyod at the hands of Minneapolis Police, and the sudden flowering of DEI work at colleges. She says “I was interested in this sort of central contradiction of diversity work, which is something that is almost posed against itself, to the extent that the formation of the committee is the work.” I hadn’t made this overt connection while reading the book, but it’s the type of really successful allegory that only speculative fiction can execute. By divorcing an idea so much from its realistic particulars, you’re able to strike at the heart of a topic in interesting and novel ways. It’s part of the beauty of this genre, and few authors succeed at bridging two worlds as successfully as Samatar did. 

This book is going to resonate most with readers who like to engage with these deeper meanings. The worldbuilding and characters and plot are all skillfully executed, but ultimately in service to getting you to contemplate and reflect. While the chains and anklets are objectively horrific, they also become ingrained cultural elements for the community, symbols built from their communal experiences. Samatar seeks to go beyond 'chain bad' and push the reader to go deeper than the surface level understanding of oppression that is more common in speculative fiction. It’s a much more nuanced take than most Dystopian explorations of classism manage to achieve. 

What Didn’t Work for Me
There’s nothing about this novella that I can say is bad or poorly done. I truly think that it executed vision flawlessly, down to an ambiguous ending that is likely the bright spot before something truly horrible happens. The worst I can say about it is that I think it’s going to fade from my memory, whereas my favorites tend to linger in my brain. There aren’t any substantive or meaningful complaints from me though, and I thought this is the type of novella I’d like to continue to see get Hugo nominations. 

Conclusion: a theme heavy exploration of classism in academic institutions, melded with a science fiction slave narrative

Novella Bingo Card
I plan on having a novella-themed bingo card this year. I originally mood read and slotted in choices, but at this point I'm close enough that I can see the light at the end of the tunnel. I still won't read something just for the bingo card (other than the middle grade square), but I can taste a finished card! Here's where I stand so far 


r/Fantasy 1d ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions Thread - July 21, 2026

40 Upvotes

Welcome to the daily recommendation requests and simple questions thread, now 1025.83% more adorable than ever before!

Stickied/highlight slots are limited, so please remember to like and subscribe upvote this thread for visibility on the subreddit <3

——

This thread is to be used for recommendation requests or simple questions that are small/general enough that they won’t spark a full thread of discussion.

Check out r/Fantasy's 2026 Book Bingo Card here!

As usual, first have a look at the sidebar in case what you're after is there. The r/Fantasy wiki contains links to many community resources, including "best of" lists, flowcharts, the LGTBQ+ database, and more. If you need some help figuring out what you want, think about including some of the information below:

  • Books you’ve liked or disliked
  • Traits like prose, characters, or settings you most enjoy
  • Series vs. standalone preference
  • Tone preference (lighthearted, grimdark, etc)
  • Complexity/depth level

Be sure to check out responses to other users' requests in the thread, as you may find plenty of ideas there as well. Happy reading, and may your TBR grow ever higher!

——

tiny image link to make the preview show up correctly

art credit: special thanks to our artist, Himmis commissions, who we commissioned to create this gorgeous piece of art for us with practically no direction other than "cozy, magical, bookish, and maybe a gryphon???" We absolutely love it, and we hope you do too.