r/FantasticFour • u/Competitive_Side6301 • 8h ago
Questions & Discussion How the F4 views Doom and The Maker
There is an interesting divide between the family, specifically between Reed and the other 3, on how they view Doom vs how they view the Maker.
Now obviously I understand that it’s all up to the different writer’s interpretation, but let’s just say we go with it and think it’s all true at once.
Reed, as many of you know, is a very hopeful man. Not just to towards the future, but towards everyone being their best selves. Even a very evil person like Victor. Even after everything Victor has done, Reed still wants to help him. His wife, his best friend, and his little brother think he’s crazy, but he’ll never give up, nor should he. Reed fights for everyone.
So….. why not the Maker??? Why is it that when the Maker asked him if he’s erase him from existence, Reed said he would. It was a cold, merciless, and assured “Yes”.
Now on the flipside, the family hates Doom’s guts and wants him far away from them. They love Reed’s heart but they don’t quite match his sense of hope.
But….. they do for Maker?? Why is Susan saying that nobody is beyond redemption even though she hates Victor for hurting her loved ones so much. Seems like a bit of a contradiction for both sides of this divide.
It seems as though two different things are happening here.
Reed will exact compassion to anyone who needs it. Except for himself. He is so guilt ridden, so self critical, and so burdened by responsibility that he does not have a high opinion of himself. That’s probably why he’s so self-sacrificial to the point that it drives Susan crazy. He thinks he’s disposable and should only be producing value. So when he sees an evil version of himself he has zero compassion. Just contempt and a desire to erase him.
The family on the other hand…. They are just looking at another version of the man they deeply love. He’s a completely different person and almost nothing like their Reed, but it doesn’t matter because he COULD be like their Reed and so they don’t think he’s beyond redemption despite how nasty he is. And this love is special since they don’t exact it to a similarly evil person like Victor.
It kinda goes to show how Reed, no matter how good he is, does not actually think he’s worthy of love. But he truly has no idea how much his wife, his best friend, and his little brother, actually, boundlessly, love him.
Again though, this is all my headcanon. Maybe North’s version of Reed does want to save the Maker too but I’d find it interesting if Maker is the ONE person Reed has no mercy for.
If Victor ever does come back (and he always does), I hope this gets explored by the next writer. I do also hope the next writer is a good one who emphasizes the bond of the family.
Thank you for reading. Goodbye.

