r/BSTsquishmallow May 08 '26

Some Selling Reminders and Expectations

24 Upvotes

Hello everyone!!

Thank you for your continued interest and engagement in this sub. We hope you have been able to conduct good transactions.

We wanted to step in here and just post a few reminders for selling as we've had a few cases here and there. I know that several of you are new here and some of you might be new to selling even if you are not new here. Here are some guidelines you are REQUIRED to follow based on our rules.

  1. Your post must have majority squishmallows. It's ok if you throw in a few non-squish plushes to sell but this is a squishmallow sub and your posts should be primarily squish.
  2. You may not post negative content about resellers or other users on the sub. Please approach us with concerns and we can address things there. This is a sub for postitivity and kindness.
  3. Your prices must be within general community expectations. We do not support resellers (defined as those who buy squish just to resell them at a severely inflated price). In general, $1 per inch in size (~$0.40 per cm) is a great start but you as the seller have a right to charge more depending on the squish. If your prices aren't fair, people won't buy and you'll get negative feedback.

Now, some other expectations. Consider these things you pretty much should always do but we don't have official rules for.

  1. List your prices in the post or comments. People are more likely to buy or reach out to you if you disclose your prices directly in the post.
  2. We try to promote the first come, first serve idea. You as the seller to have the final right to determine what "first" means (first person to DM, first person to pay, first person to comment, etc.) but you should clearly communicate when a squish is "on hold". Be prepared to have a list of who to contact next if the first person falls through.
  3. Include your reddit username on a sticky note in your pictures. This helps establish trust that you didn't steal photos and that you actually have the squish you say you do. Be prepared to send more photos over DM if a buyer asks (and try to include your username in those photos as well).
  4. Many sellers charge for shipping. This is ok and expected. However, as a seller make sure to say that buyers are responsible for shipping in the post. Be prepared to create a shipping estimate to certain zip codes/areas if asked (https://postcalc.usps.com/). However, your final total charged to the buyer should be the actual cost (send receipts of shipping charge if necessary). AVOID as much as you can asking for more money after the buyer has already paid. This looks very much like scam behavior and makes buyers very worries.
  5. Once a squish has sold, clearly communicate the tracking number and when you expect to ship it out. It is ok to ship out multiple orders in bulk and wait a day or two but you should ship quickly and communicate each step of the process.

If you as a seller are unable to handle these expectations or to handle many orders at once, only post a few squish at a time. These guidelines and criteria above are what we use when investigating complaints or scam alerts. The more you follow the better all our experiences will be!

Thank you all. Let us know if you have questions or if you think there are any errors here (totally could be, had a long day today!). Happy squishing!


r/BSTsquishmallow 6h ago

bst (from usa) Squishmallow Bundles for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Smoke free /pet free /display only/ bundled deals /accepting reasonable offers but priced to sell please - Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 4h ago

bst (from usa) Tons of Squishmallows for sale

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I have them all posted on Mercari and super flexible with price. Not sure if I’m allowed to post my Mercari or not but dm me if interested in any!! Some with tags some without


r/BSTsquishmallow 21h ago

bst (from usa) JT Mallow Moods For Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

$11+ship

New with tags, sticker, and box.

PayPal & Venmo accepted, ships from smoke free home.


r/BSTsquishmallow 18h ago

bst (from usa) I have a lot of squishmallows posted on d3p0p

6 Upvotes

I have a lot of my squishmallows posted on D3p0p that I collected and need gone


r/BSTsquishmallow 16h ago

bst (from usa) I need all of my squishmallows gone I have them listed on D/: p0p at a fair price most have all of their hang tags But some don’t but they are in perfect condition I just need them gone I am moving and I do not collect anymore , I have photos listed down below my user for that app is @chloewillo8

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow 1d ago

bst (from usa) Cow & Bigfoot Bundles for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Selling most of my collection as bundled deals. 🥲 New with tags. Smoke free /pet free home. Display only. Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 1d ago

bst (from usa) Patty Bundle for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Tote NWOT, Fuzzamallow NWT, Squishville NWT & clip NWT - selling as bundled lot! Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 1d ago

bst (from usa) Ronnie Bundle for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Ronnie & friends! NWT. Smoke/ pet free. Display only. Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 1d ago

bst (from usa) [US ONLY] Squish & Accessory Sale - Squishmallows, Sanrio

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Clearing out some of my collection! Item price+ship (pirateship)

All items ship within the US via USPS Ground Advantage.

I will be sending the paid for items together with a relative visiting from US. He will touch down in the US on 2 Aug and the items will be mailed out by 4-6 Aug!

Paypal only. Idm giving my personal number for a video packing and will keep all buyers updated.

SQUISHMALLOWS & ACCESSORIES:

All without paper hangtags except Bubba, TuxedoSam, Hawk clip.

Eden x2 Bubba (its a bag!) Theotto 10" Theotto with Pumpkin Spice Hawk clip Jericho x2 Chienda

Some miscellaneous soft toys. The red one, Alphabet Lore has a paper hangtag.

📌 Will be posting other stuff in other forums, do check out my profile!


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Connor Bundle for Sale!

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

All NWT except 1 Squishville. Selling as a lot!


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Trading/selling

Post image
7 Upvotes

Update: SOLD


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Cow Bundles for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Selling as bundles. NWT. Display only. Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Halloween Squish Bundle

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Halloween Squishmallows, clips & Micromallow. Selling as a bundle.

New with tags
Smoke free/pet free
Display only

Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) 💕 Squishmallow Clear Out 💕 Buyer pays shipping 🙂 feel free to comment or message me which one/ones you are interested in. Open to offers 🙂 most have their hang tags, a few are like new without tags. Adult collector owned. Displayed only.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Up for sale!

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

bst (from usa) Selling Theotto the Cthulhu Keychain & big plush! (dont talk to me or my son ever again)

Post image
7 Upvotes

NWOT! A very cute pair. Owned by an adult collector, so in great condition. I think these are coveted little guys, priced for roughly what I paid for the pair. They're listed on my depop (@lonalynn). $40 w/free shipping.

Open to selling on other platforms (ex: Mercari, Poshmark).

If you'd like more photos, feel free to ask! :)


r/BSTsquishmallow 2d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ any isos from 5b?

2 Upvotes

if anyone is interested in any 5b lines from before late 2025, any specifics can go in the comments below. have tons, looking to purge most of the collection.


r/BSTsquishmallow 3d ago

bst (from usa) UFS BOGO Free, Buyer pays shipping

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow 3d ago

bst (from usa) Mallow Mood Trades

4 Upvotes

Would anyone be interested in trading for Mallow Moods? I have several up for trade - Borothy, JT, Wallis, and Nanette. Up for considering any trade offer, not just other mallow moods but I am searching for the Erm of the bunch!


r/BSTsquishmallow 3d ago

bst (from usa) Selling 12” Terrell Select Series

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Selling 12” Terrell Select Series with tag for $25 plus ship. Shipping from the US


r/BSTsquishmallow 4d ago

bst (from usa) Selling: 2 rare series 2 squishmallow cards

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Mallowstyles 1/1 $125

Squishsquad out of 10 $20

$130 for both!

My daughter got them and wants to sell to get squishies or something like that


r/BSTsquishmallow 5d ago

bst (from usa) Still a Lot For Sale! Going by price point now. Everyone is $5 each unless they are <5” then They’re 2 for $5

Post image
10 Upvotes

For anyone more comfortable with platforms I’m willing to post on Mercari and Depop especially bundles


r/BSTsquishmallow 4d ago

bst (from usa) Downsizing!!

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Only trying to sell! Open to giving better discounts to larger bundles 🩷


r/BSTsquishmallow 5d ago

bst (from usa) Hey Friends! Looking for more forever homes for some of my plush.

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Thanks so much to those who took some of my plush from my last post.

I sent a few DMs to later replies who were interested, so if you see ones that you responded to in my last post, please check your messages!

There’s a few new ones here, and I might add some more Squishmallows and Pokemon in the future. If you have a DISO or ISO from 2021-2023 let me know! I might have it. I have a ton of axolotls that are not pictured here.