r/ArchiCAD • u/Rockstonerable • 1d ago
discussions I tested a dozen PDF editors on a heavy ArchiCAD export for pan and zoom smoothness. Bluebeam surprised me. Trying to build an open list, what do you use?
Disclosure first, because it matters: I make one of the tools in this test (Ncored). So I am biased, I will not tell you how mine did, and I would rather this becomes a shared list we build together than an ad for my own tool. Judge all of it yourself.
I am a practising architect. Slow PDFs on heavy drawings have been a low-grade annoyance for years, so as a side project I took one dense drawing exported from ArchiCAD and opened it in about a dozen PDF editors, on one Windows PC and one Mac, doing the same thing in each: open it, then scroll, zoom and pan around the busy areas. The file and the exact steps are downloadable (link below), so anyone can re-run it and check my read.
A few things surprised me:
- Bluebeam Revu, the one I expected to win, was not the smoothest on this dense drawing. Once it is open it loads a drawing fast, and nothing touches its markup tools or Studio, no argument there. But on pan the view kept flashing white and reloading the main layers before the detail came back. If you are a heavy Revu user and yours behaves differently, please tell me, I want to get this right.
- PDF-XChange Editor was one of the smoothest, which I did not see coming. The interface looks like an older Windows toolbar though, so whether it suits you is a matter of taste.
- A couple of the consumer editors either went choppy on the dense areas or could not load the drawing at all.
What I actually want from you:
What do you open and mark up your ArchiCAD PDF sets in day to day, and does it stay smooth when the layout gets dense?
What should I add to the test? I want the list to be complete, so name anything you think belongs, and tell me if you think I scored one wrong.
I will add the ones you suggest and re-run them on the same file, so it stays a shared reference rather than a one-off. The recordings and the downloadable drawing are here: https://ncored.com/pdf-benchmark-cad-drawings.html
P.s. My hardware and my file are not yours, so treat it as one data point.
