Foam acoustics product that are not explicitly rated as being fire resistant have no purpose whatsoever in your studio, bedroom, basement, dog kennel, stored under your bed for a future project, or anywhere else. They are gasoline. Quite literally, they are made from petroleum.
Aside from the fact the only real absorption they offer is for every piece of dust, debris, strand of hair, and odor they come in contact with, they are extraordinarily flammable.
If you have not seen the videos of what happened in Bangkok this weekend, don't. It's absolutely horrifying. That fire has claimed the lives of 33 people so far, and in an instant there was a flashover that would've made you think there was a dragon breathing fire out of the main entrance into the street.
They are still investigating the initial cause of the fire, but in looking at the before and after photos, a few things are obvious:
- In prior photos of the venue (shown above), every possible surface that could've had foam "treatments" did. Ceilings, walls, columns, and even the front of the bar.
- In aftermath photos, the room and structure are in surprisingly good shape all things considered. It's almost exclusively the interior treatments and finishes that went up in flames.
- If not for the abundance of highly flammable foam treatments and the associated toxic smoke, it's highly likely this incident would've been unremarkable with no injuries. Maybe refunded cover fees and a phone call to an electrician.
As to the acoustical performance of eggcrate-style foam products, if you were to crosscheck laboratory test data on the average eggcrate "acoustic" foam, you may notice it does very little for mid-band frequencies and nothing for low frequencies. Per unit of area, it's on average about half of the absorption of fabric-wrapped fiberglass panels. Meaning, while it's very cheap to cover a lot of area with -- you can get the same performance from fabric-wrapped panels while only purchasing half as much coverage.
If I sound a tad arrogant here, I can't apologize or be kind about this. This lesson has been learned time and time again with dozens of bodies per incident to show for it. Let us not forget the Station Nightclub Fire that claimed the lives of 100 people and maimed hundreds others. Same disclaimer applies -- if you have not seen the videos from the Station Nightclub Fire -- don't, unless you are the kind of person who after reading all of this is still thinking about buying or keeping unrated, highly flammable, highly toxic foam treatments.
If you must see the Station Nightclub Fire video as evidence though, here it is.
- The fire ignited from on-stage pyro at 0:20, quickly spreading across the foam panels they had used to treat the stage area.
- 30 seconds later, there was a crowd-crush toward the exits.
- 37 seconds after ignition, the fire alarms went off.
- 75 seconds after ignition, all you can hear is the fire alarm and blood-curdling screams.
- By 100 seconds after ignition -- under 2 minutes, there was a stack of bodies 4ft deep that people were trampling over to get out (not 4ft front-to-back...4ft floor to ceiling). Many who perished never made it near the door and got stuck in the bathrooms or other areas because of the thick, toxic smoke that the foam treatments generated. They couldn't see even 6 inches in front of them.
- By the time the fire trucks showed up roughly 5 minutes after ignition, it was all over. The building was engulfed.
So imagine that you have treated your spare bedroom with these products -- and for whatever reason they ignite while you are asleep. It is highly likely by the time you wake up that the fire has already spread and created blinding smoke throughout your entire residence. If you're lucky, there may still be time for you to stumble outside if the choking superheated smoke doesn't get you first, but the odds you will have time to save loved ones or pets is quite low. You will probably succumb to the smoke and superheated gasses first.
Friends don't let friends, or even enemies, use common unrated foam products as acoustic treatments.