TW: physical violence between adult siblings
I am a 26(f), and my older brother is 35. This happened this evening, so I am still processing everything.
I want to preface this by saying that I genuinely do not currently feel in danger, and I do not believe this will happen again. I know people often say that after something serious happens, but that is honestly how I feel right now.
My two brothers and I have essentially been one another’s support system for years. Our father left our mother, although they are still legally married. It is complicated and connected to family and cultural dynamics that are common in many African cultures/families. Much of our extended family also turned their backs on us or behaved in ways that made us stop trusting them.
There has also been a lot of stress surrounding our parents’ health. My father previously had a stroke and epileptic attacks and was recently treated for skin cancer. My mother went through intensive spinal surgery.
I will acknowledge that I can have an extremely sharp tongue, particularly when I am stressed or anxious. My brother, on the other hand, is known to have a temper. He can also be patronising toward me and sometimes acts as though I must defer to him because he is older and because he is a man, even when he was disrespectful first.
We have had heated disagreements before, but they have never become physical.
He also has ongoing problems with his spouse that he tends to bottle up. My other brother and I have tried to support him and even bought him a sim racing setup because it is something he loves and we hoped it would give him an outlet. I cannot know whether any of that stress contributed to what happened, but I suspect the level of anger was not entirely about me.
My brother and I work for the same organisation. Our departments are based on the same floor, but we are in different departments, and he usually works from other buildings. We normally carpool.
This evening, we were returning from work in my car, with my brother driving.
Close to my neighbourhood, he wanted to turn left onto a very narrow road that only had enough space for one car. Another car was coming from that road and intended to turn right, but our car was occupying the space the driver needed to complete the turn.
My brother expected the other driver to temporarily turn left, allow us to pass into the narrow road, reverse, and then make the right turn the driver had originally intended.
The two drivers remained at a standstill. My brother kept signalling for the other car to move and said that he had the whole day to stand there.
I repeatedly suggested two alternatives. The first was for my brother to move forward slightly so that the other car could complete its intended right turn. We could then reverse and make the left turn my brother wanted.
The second was simply to continue straight. His preferred left turn would have put us approximately one minute from home, while continuing straight would have put us approximately two minutes from home.
I was tired after work and did not understand why we were having an extended standoff over a difference of roughly one minute, especially when there was another way for him to make the left turn.
I eventually said something along the lines of, “As the owner of the car, can we please just go home? It has been a long day.”
He then continued straight.
After we drove away, he told me that I should not have interfered. I replied that I had not spoken to the other driver at all. I had only spoken to him inside my own car.
He told me to mind my business. I replied that my car was my business and that I wanted to go home. I recognise that my car comment was pointed and possibly mean in the way I delivered it.
He told me to shut up. I refused because I did not believe the argument made sense. He called me stupid, and I called him stupid back. He raised his voice, and I raised mine. There was a bit of back and forth with the “shutting up” and “no, because it involves my car” comments.
He said I was disrespecting him and that I should respect him because he was older. I said that maturity was not determined by age.
When we arrived at the house, he repeatedly told me not to anger him and said that I would not like what he would do.
I kept asking what he intended to do.
He then said that if I had balls, I should get out of the car. I am a woman, so the wording was obviously intended as a challenge.
I got out through the passenger side and remained standing beside the passenger side of the car.
He got out through the driver’s side, came around the car to where I was standing and slapped me.
I slapped him back after he hit me. He then continued hitting me until I fell.
I tried to kick him in the groin. When I managed to get up, I slapped him again, and his glasses and phone fell. He then hit and kicked me multiple times, and I fell again.
Only after he had already struck me repeatedly did I tell him to hit me if he wanted to hit me so badly (as I had adrenaline running and was clearly heated and upset).
When he appeared to be leaving, I said that I was not his spouse, referring to her by name (definitely fucked up more here).
Again, I made this comment only after he had already slapped, hit and kicked me repeatedly.
After I mentioned his wife, he came back and hit me again. He told me not to speak about his wife. I called him a coward.
Our groundskeeper (from where we are from, it is common to have help around the house for middle class households) tried to separate us, and my other brother, whom I will call M, eventually separated us.
I had blood around my nose, facial swelling, a headache (feeling the headache now) and a broken nail. I used ice, and the swelling appeared to go down somewhat. I am honestly also sad about the nail, even though I know it is the least serious injury (girl problems haha).
M asked me what had happened, and I told him my version. My older brother went to tell our mother his version.
Our mother became extremely distressed, and her blood pressure appeared to rise. She began blaming herself because the journey and detour (she had asked me to buy something for the house) had partly involved something connected to her. She said something about demons trying to destroy our family after we had maintained harmony through everything involving our father. For context, she is very religious and where we are from “botânicas” are used to spread misfortune to others/or bring you ‘fortune’ (love,money) at a cost, which adds to her superstition.
M and I both reassured her that none of this was her fault.
M later spoke to both of us. He gave me a lecture about how both sides were wrong and asked whether I was willing to reconcile.
I said that I was eventually willing to reconcile, but only if both of us apologised for our own behaviour without adding “but” or “if” afterwards (the apologies were supposed to happen tonight and the reconciliation after we both cooled down).
I can acknowledge that I raised my voice, retaliated by calling him stupid and keep emphasising that it was my car, and the wife comment (very rude of me, but it wasn’t the catalyst of the argument).
What I do not accept is that those things made me equally responsible for him threatening me and continuously striking me.
My brother apparently wanted us to have the reconciliation conversation that same evening. I did not think that was sensible, as one badly chosen sentence from either of us could have caused another confrontation.
M asked whether I wanted to press charges. I said no at the time because it could affect my brother’s job and reputation. He is also the only breadwinner in his household, so the consequences would affect his spouse and children.
I also suspect that he had a lot of bottled-up anger about other things and that I was in the wrong place at the wrong time and said the wrong thing.
However, I made it clear that if he ever touches me like that again, I will report him and he will be going to jail.
M later said that my brother sounded apologetic and regretted what happened because he had never hit a woman before. However, his explanation apparently included that the “disrespect got to him,” which concerns me because it still sounds like a justification.
My brother has a history of saying, “I’m sorry, but…” and then explaining what the other person did to make him react that way.
Approximately an hour after he returned to his own house, my brother sent me an apology. He said that he did not mean to hurt me and that he hoped I could find it in myself for us to move on.
I have not responded because I do not currently have the energy.
He also contacted our father himself and told him that we had had a serious argument that became physical.
I had intended to keep this completely private. I did not want to say a word about it to anyone outside the people who were already present. However, my brother broke that dam by telling our father.
I do not know whether he told him because he felt guilty, because he wanted support or because he wanted to establish his version before I could tell mine. It may have been genuine remorse, damage control or some combination of both.
My father later contacted me to ask whether I was okay. I replied that I was fine, thanked him for checking on me and said that we could speak at a more convenient time because I needed to sleep and prepare for a work meeting.
I am now worried that my father may tell my estranged sister and other siblings (all of whom share the same father as me, and were conceived out of wedlock when my dad had already married my mom; my eldest was from a separate relationship before he met my mom). She may then tell members of our extended family, which could turn this into a much larger family issue that I never wanted.
Avoiding my brother completely is not realistic.
Although we work for the same organisation and our departments are based on the same floor, we are in separate departments, and he usually works from different buildings. Workplace contact may therefore be limited.
The family home is more complicated. He comes here regularly because of our mother and brings his children so that she can spend time with her grandchildren. I do not want to interfere with my mother seeing her grandchildren, and I am not asking anyone to prevent him from visiting. However, this means he will continue to be around me.
Before this happened, he had also asked to borrow my car for the weekend to travel to his spouse’s hometown because his own car is still broken down. I had plans, although those plans may now be cancelled, so he was supposed to use our mother’s car instead.
Even if my plans are cancelled, I am no longer comfortable allowing him to use my car. I am worried that withdrawing permission may become another argument, particularly because this entire incident began while he was driving my vehicle.
We will also not be carpooling for the time being.
I genuinely do not feel that I am in immediate danger, but I also do not want family pressure to make me move on before I have processed what happened.
What boundaries would be reasonable when he will continue visiting the family home?
How should I respond to his apology when he has a pattern of apologising and then adding “but”?
How should I handle the fact that he told our father and that this may now spread to the rest of my family?
Am I being unfair by distinguishing between taking responsibility for my hurtful words and accepting responsibility for him initiating the violence?
TL;DR: My 35 year old brother and I argued after I asked him to end an unnecessary road standoff while he was driving my car. When we arrived home, he threatened me and challenged me to get out. I got out and remained beside the passenger side. He came around from the driver’s side to where I was standing, slapped me first and then repeatedly hit and kicked me. He later apologised and told our father before I had decided whether to disclose what happened. He regularly visits our mother, had planned to borrow my car and will continue to be around me, so I need advice about boundaries, accountability and possible reconciliation.