r/InfertilitySucks • u/CauliflowerNational1 • 2h ago
advice wanted Would it be wrong to call out my SIL's infertility story?
My husband (28M) and I (28F) have been trying to conceive for almost five years. Four of those years were fertility treatments (IUI, IVF, surgeries) and a formal infertility diagnosis from endometriosis. I have never been pregnant.
My BIL (24M) and his wife (22F) got married in September 2024. They were open about using protection, and this January she was telling people she was scared of getting pregnant and having kids. She was diagnosed with PCOS in March and conceived around late April.
They announced the pregnancy to us with a handwritten card. In it she wrote that doctors had told her she was infertile, that she'd been praying about whether they should adopt, that God had done a miracle for them, and, my favorite line, "I know He will do a miracle in yours.". We believe in God, so that's not the issue.
The same card mentions she was prescribed birth control and metformin (I don't know why she felt the need to include that). That's standard PCOS management for someone who isn't trying to conceive. PCOS is a common cause of infertility, but a PCOS diagnosis isn't an infertility diagnosis, and nobody gets one after a few months of trying, least of all someone who wasn't trying.
We weren't obviously weren't overjoyed when we read it. Since it's hard so hear pregnancy announcements, especially for me. Because of this, they gave us the cold shoulder. My husband asked his brother about it and he admitted they were hurt by our reaction. When I asked SIL directly, she said they were "giving me space". By ignoring me while I'm trying to talk to them?!
We sorted through that issue. But, now she's now telling everyone the good news, and that she was told she was infertile and conceived anyway. It's becoming the story of their pregnancy.
I don't want to make a scene. But if she says it in front of me, I want to ask how she got an infertility diagnosis if they weren't even trying to conceive and were using protection.
My husband thinks I should let it go, and part of me knows that's the mature answer. The other part has spent five years as a lab rat and can't listen to someone describe a few weeks of fear in the same words.
They also live in our mother-in-law suite, so there's no avoiding her either way.