I feel like I might get downvoted for saying this… but everything this season feels just way too gamed out. Like they focused so much on the game design itself that they forgot to make it… funny?
Every episode feels like a bunch of mini games in a trenchcoat, rather than just taking a simple premise to its logical extreme. This is best exemplified by the most recent episode, Count The Rice, which honestly just felt like an excuse to shove in a bunch of games that they couldn’t think where else to use them.
But even the best episodes so far this season feel similar, like they felt obligated to include a bunch of props and set pieces not because they added to the game but because it’s what they think we “expect” from Game Changer.
Take Kangaroo Court, probably my favorite episode of the season, mostly because it actually has a fairly simple hook and any episode featuring Brennan, Vic, and Aabria is going to be funny. In the BTS Ryan Creamer mentions his original pitch was to just do one minigame and then spend the whole episode litigating it… and honestly, I think that would have been better! Imagine if they got to call witnesses, present evidence, cross examine each other, all over the minutiae of one fairly basic mini game.
But instead they felt like they needed to add more because “that would be too simple for a full episode.”
And it works fine as is, like I said it’s still maybe my favorite of the season (its neck and neck with Don’t Wake Standards & Practices), but I feel like leaning into the simplicity and the minutiae might have been better.
Some of the best episodes are deceptively simple: Sam Says, Yes or No, the OG Make Some Noise.
Hell even the OG Rulette was perfect in its simplicity… Rulette 2 just way overdid it with the Golden Rule, Australia mode, giving Sam and Paul rules… it was fun in a chaotic sort of way but it really missed that little spark of joy that made the original such a classic.
Maybe I’m just being a grump. I dunno. I am at least happy that props and set dec are getting a lot of work this season, but I don’t think I can do another episode that’s just a bunch of thinly tied together mini games.
Paul F Tompkins was right. Sam is a weird little mini game freak.