I've been on this network long enough ( 10 years ) to see the pattern. VATSIM isnt a "realistic simulation community" anymore. Its a playground for bitter old timers who get off on gatekeeping, a dumping ground for trolls that supervisors refuse to deal with, and a place where "standards" only apply to newcomers while the old guard does whatever they want.
The hypocrisy is honestly laughable. An ex ATM admits they had a live event with 40 drunk people and mishaps happened? "Loosen up, its a game."
A newbie asks a simple question? "You dont have the commitment, the network isnt for you."
A pilot meows on frequency and screams "Im being raped" for a laugh? Nothing happens.
Someone tries to provide facts and technical arguments about how the network could evolve? Downvoted into oblivion.
Controllers are quitting because they cant deal with the disrespect anymore. "Most of us dont deal with it. Thats why so many of us are former vatsim controllers."
Meanwhile, supervisors are useless. "A wallop is pointless these days. Supervisors are not going to do anything."
But the hardcore defenders will still type: "But we have standards." Yeah? What standards? The standard where you can be a condescending prick and get 20 upvotes? The standard where you gatekeep beginners while the network slowly dies from lack of new blood?
And IMO the best part is that these same people who scream about "quality control" and "maintaining standards" are the ones who downvote anyone with a new idea, treat the network like their personal little kingdom, talk to newcomers like theyre absolute garbage, then turn around and say "were so welcoming here."
No. Youre not welcoming. You're a circlejerk of bitter middle aged guys who get a power trip from pretending to be an air traffic controller in a video game.
A real life private pilot said they were scared to push the PTT button because of the "roasting" on Reddit posts. And you know what the response was? Not "we should be more welcoming." No. It was: "Good. VATSIM isnt meant for beginners."
Youre literally proud of scaring away people who are genuinely trying to learn.
So here is the reality check.
This network is going to die. Not because of "MSFS kids" or "trolls." Its going to die because the community has become so toxic and elitist that good controllers quit from burnout, new pilots are too scared to join, innovation and new ideas get shot down by gatekeepers, supervisors dont enforce rules, and "standards" are just a tool to exclude people the old guard doesnt like.
You want to save the network? Stop jerking yourselves off about how "realistic" and "professional" you are while treating people like garbage.
Downvote this all you want. Its easier than actually looking in the mirror.