r/surgery Feb 08 '25

Medical advice posts are NOT ALLOWED

48 Upvotes

Adding this announcement to the top of the sub to increase visibility.

And yes, posting “I’m not asking for advice” and then soliciting opinions about your personal health situation is very much asking for medical advice.


r/surgery 2d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What part of surgery inspires awe for you working in an OR?

28 Upvotes

For those who work in an OR, what do you see or experience that never gets old or inspires awe, if anything? What makes you think “woah that’s amazing/cool/surreal”?

Edit: I’d like to add the reason I ask is because I’d like to work in an OR someday. I shadowed and was fortunate enough to be trusted to observe 8 cases over a year. I was overwhelmed with a sense of awe and the immense privilege it is to actually see someone’s vagus nerve or their carotid or femoral artery pumping blood, to see the care with which the staff treats the patient at their most vulnerable. What you all do is amazing to me, truly. I think about it every day as I work toward my higher ed goals. Thank you for what you do.


r/surgery 2d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules do the intestines curl and move around during surgery?

29 Upvotes

im not a doctor, im not smart, please be nice. do the intestines move during surgery to the point where they have to be held in place. someone told me this, ive questoned it for a while now, tried researching and have decided now to bite the bullet of embaressment and just ask the doctor people who have a degree and, unlike me, know things


r/surgery 4d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Is this okay???? Scalp laceration

Post image
53 Upvotes

Guys i hope i did better than my prev one

Thanks a lot for the support and tips


r/surgery 6d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Do Surgeons (And Patients!!) Actually Prefer using Surgical robots like the DV5?

22 Upvotes

Hey all, first-time poster. I have a close family member who is a surgeon, and we were recently having a debate about robotic surgery (at the dinner table). He was saying that robotic surgery is the future and should be everywhere, because even though it may cost some more money in overhead, it's far less load-bearing than laparoscopic procedures on him (especially as he and his colleagues get older), and the difference in timing isn't all that bad anymore. Curious to hear any of your thoughts, if you prefer using a DV, and especially if the patients who have had procedures from a DV even have noticeably different outcomes? He mentioned that more residents and young surgeons are becoming "robot-native," but again curious to hear your experiences there as well. Thanks!


r/surgery 7d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules E chirurgia asa rea precum se spune?

8 Upvotes

In viata mea de student, dar si inainte, am fost atras strict de chirurgie.Dar acum la moda este sa ti alegi, mai presus decat ceva ce sa ti placa, o specializare care te lasa sa traiesti, si comentariile negative ma fac sa ma feresc de aceasta specialitate.Am tot fost in practica si la stagii pe diverse sectii de chirurgie generala si absolut peste toti mi s au parut doctori care nu stau rancezi in fata ta, care iti explica si care au simtul umorului.Nu mi s a spus niciodata da- te la o parte ca incurci, ca pe alte sectii.Deci care e faza?De ce e chirurgia generala blamata ca este printre cele mai proaste alegeri?Mi se pare foarte low cortisol si high reward.


r/surgery 8d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Studying for mrcs and tips? Also any anki decks?

1 Upvotes

👀 sos


r/surgery 8d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Appendix

0 Upvotes

Hello guys
I just had a thought about appendix surgery

Can the surgery be done with out full anaesthesia only local one ?
And if no why so ?


r/surgery 9d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Proposal: Should we retire the term “acute appendicitis”?

0 Upvotes

The diagnosis of appendicitis can only be made when the appendix is under a pathologists microscope.. ..and small tumours in the appendix can’t be distinguished from an inflamed appendix - they tend to be radiological occult..

The diagnosis “acute appendicitis” implies a specific disease entity when it is actually a syndrome with multiple possible causes. In many cases we do not know whether we are dealing with infection, obstruction, or an underlying neoplasm.

I propose replacing it with a two-stage framework:

• Stage 1: Suspected Appendiceal Pathology (initial presentation)

• Stage 2: Confirmed Appendiceal Pathology (only after histology)

This would make it clear to patients that choosing non-operative management means accepting management of a syndrome without ever establishing a true diagnosis.

Has anyone explored a similar re-framing of the diagnosis? I’d be interested in your thoughts.


r/surgery 12d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What’s up with paediatric surgery?

5 Upvotes

I’m sure enough to realise that i wanna pursue my medical career as surgeron. And i got a 7** rank(19th batch) as a general candidate in this years inicet. So obviously I’m not gonna get general surgery or any of the two 6 year super speciality courses i filled in my choices. What’s still an option is paediatric surgery. But it seems like it’s such a niche branch that I haven’t been able to get any feedback from any of my seniors. Also I do plan to apply for licensing exams abroad. So it’s a request to my seniors, someone plz help me out here should i go for paediatric surgery in the open round or try my luck for general surgery in the upcoming neet pg?


r/surgery 13d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Where can I find videos of surgeries?!

20 Upvotes

I don’t study or work in medicine but I’m considering getting some plastic surgery done and would love to see a procedure, struggling to find anything would appreciate any resources? Are all the vids kept behind a paywall or something ?!

I also very likely don’t even know the vocabulary to best search so if that’s the issue, grateful for insight, I wanna find vid of breast lifts & breast implants. Maybe vids of facial work too.

P.S. were you guys there when plastic surgeons were posting clips of their active surgeries on Snapchat stories in like 2016-2019ish? I saw many ab walls get stitched up lol


r/surgery 14d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Is it true that hospitals will do anything they can to keep you alive if you code on the operating table just so they can move you to another location before pronouncing you solely to keep OR death statistics low?

29 Upvotes

r/surgery 14d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Any legit paid surveys for doctors?

3 Upvotes

I've looked into a few survey platforms over the years and most of them either screened me out constantly or paid so little that it wasn't worth finishing. Maybe I've just had bad luck.

A colleague recently told me there are platforms that specifically target doctors, but I haven't spent much time researching them yet. Before I go signing up for a bunch of sites, I figured I'd ask here.

Has anyone found any legit paid surveys for doctors that are actually worth doing?

f/u: Thanks everyone. I ended up trying a few of your recommendations. I had the most success with Sermo so far. The specialty focus seems to make a big difference compared with the general survey sites I've tried before, and I've already completed a few surveys without too much hassle.


r/surgery 19d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Flatulence and sterile field in the OR

29 Upvotes

Saw a funny video about a doctor experimenting flatulence and its safety in the OR. So it seems that if the flatulence is through some type of fabric/clothes its safe to do. But what if the patient is prone on the table and rips one? There's also situations where the patient has to flip mid case to finish surgery.

  1. Is flatulence aerosol?

  2. If so, and youre the patient in the OR amd you rip one, is your own gut & skin bacteria safe during surgery and it wont break the sterile field?


r/surgery 22d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What was the survival rate for surgical procedures in ancient times, as microbiology and infection were not understood at that point in time?

14 Upvotes

I’m a medical student, I was discussing this with a team of surgery Residents today, in context of cesarean sections, which have been around for thousands of years.

What precautions did physicians use to prevent infections, if any? Did they use any form of antiseptic?

Did people go into surgery assuming that they would die?

How Would they suture the incisions, and did the surgical sites always get infected?
Thank you!


r/surgery 22d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules I have an interview Surgical Services Assistant role. What exposure would I have to patients, surgery’s, and physicians?

4 Upvotes

Hello all!

I just got an interview as a Surgical Services Assistant and I haven’t ever worked at a hospital before so I’m struggling to understand where I fit in the puzzle.

For background: I have my CNA and have been a nursing assistant at long term, rehab and memory care skilled nursing facilities / nursing homes. I’m currently going back to school to pursue a Physician Assistant degree and I’m hoping to get exposure to PAs and how they work in surgical settings before I get accepted into a program and commit that time and money.

The job that I got an interview for has these listed as the key job duties. Is this something that would help me see how things run, get opportunities to watch surgeries and meet surgeons, PAs, surgical nurses, etc. or is this a job that will stick me with the grunt work and not get any exposure?

Job duties:
*Responsible for preparation, set up and cleanup of assigned spaces.
*Properly identifies, handles and disposes of biohazardous, hazardous and pharmaceutical waste according to policies and procedures.
*Safely transports supplies, instrumentation and equipment needed for surgical procedures.
*Provides patient transport within the facility via stretcher, wheelchair and ambulatory assistance.
*Completes and maintains records of assigned check lists.


r/surgery 23d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Appendicitis: surgery versus non surgical management guidelines

22 Upvotes

Greetings. Pathologists’ assistant here. I have some questions about appendectomies. Obviously this is anecdotal, but is there an increasing trend of treating suspected appendicitis with antibiotics, drain, and imaging rather than surgery?

In the past week to ten days we’ve received multiple cases of presumed appendicitis that was a malignancy. By the time the malignancy caused symptoms, the cancer had spread all over the abdomen and the surgeries these patients received were en bloc resections of multiple organs.

I know that surgical guidelines are above our pay grade, and correct me if I’m wrong, but aren’t around 1-2% of appendectomies positive for malignancy? It seems as though conservative treatment is going to miss those.


r/surgery 22d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Looking to Join Surgery Systematic Reviews

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a medical student at a Canadian medical school looking to join any surgery-related systematic reviews, scoping reviews or meta-analyses. I've worked on a lot of these in the past so I have quite a bit of prior experience in this domain and would be happy to help with screening, data extraction, risk of bias, or manuscript writing. Please message me if you're looking for another collaborator


r/surgery 23d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules GUYS IS THIS OKAY??

Post image
38 Upvotes

Sutured this

Give me feedback i know i did kinda terrible job


r/surgery 23d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Fresh out of residency—what’s next? Abdominal surgery

2 Upvotes

Hello, I recently became a board-certified abdominal surgeon, and I would like to ask for your opinion/experience.

What helped you improve and continue developing on your journey as a surgeon? What did you read, and which courses did you attend? Thank you!


r/surgery 26d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Skin cancer surgery rotation flap

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for some feedback on a facial reconstruction case involving the nasal root / medial canthus area.
After excision of a small lesion near the nasal root/medial canthus, a local rotation/transposition-type flap from the glabellar/nasal root region was used. Post-op, it looked like the flap did not quite rotate/reach into the defect without tension. There was some central crusting/dehiscence at the inset area.
Any ideas what went wrong? Thanks


r/surgery 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Why don’t doctors tell patients about scar tape?

13 Upvotes

Sorry if this is not allowed, I’m not a doctor. I’ve had mohs surgery to remove a basal cell carcinoma on my face, and laparoscopic hysterectomy with 5 incisions. In both cases I was active on the respective Reddit communities. And from my own and others experiences, it seems that many surgeons do not specifically recommend their patients use scar tape/silicone gel sheets to improve the scar appearance. I have read a few studies showing how effective they are, especially for new scars. You’d think surgeons or their team or the take home printouts would at least mention it as something to look into, especially for facial scars. Why is this not the norm?


r/surgery 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Med Student Question: Beard Etiquette

8 Upvotes

Hello, I’m an OMS4 about to begin his first audition rotation in general surgery. I had a beard during third-year and got feedback from a FM resident that if, for instance, all the surgeons are cleanshaven then it’s a matter of etiquette to not be the only one wearing extra gear/coverings on the head. Or something along those lines, that being the only one with a beard is “not a good idea”. Do any attendings care if a medical student has a beard, given that he makes sure to cover it adequately in the OR? Is it more a matter of convenience to be clean shaven, or is it more of a “don’t be the odd one out” ?Apologies if it’s a strange question. Thank you!!


r/surgery 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Considering becoming a surgeon,

7 Upvotes

I'm 15 and would like advice on any books I can read or practices I can do to become more knowledgeable. Thank you


r/surgery Jun 22 '26

I did read the sidebar & rules I built a urology oral boards practice tool and could use blunt feedback

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m a urologist and I’ve been building a web-based Urology Oral Boards Coach for residents, fellows, and recent grads preparing for oral boards.

The basic idea is that you start a case and it behaves like a text-based oral boards examiner. It asks follow-up questions, withholds data unless you ask for it, pushes you on management decisions, introduces complications, and can run either in a more exam-like mode or a more teaching-heavy/open-book mode. There’s also dictation if you’d rather speak your answer and edit it before submitting.

I’m opening it as a free 7-day beta and would really appreciate blunt feedback, especially from urology residents/fellows/recent grads. No credit card needed.

Link: https://urologyboardscoach.com
Beta code: UROLOGYCOACH

The code should work for the first 30 signups. If it runs out and you still want to try it, message me directly and I can send additional invites.

Main things I’m trying to figure out: does the examiner feel realistic, are the cases detailed enough, is the feedback useful, does the scoring feel fair, and is the signup/onboarding annoying?

Obvious disclaimer: this is educational board prep, not medical advice, not affiliated with any board or society, and still very much in beta.

If you try it, I’d genuinely appreciate harsh feedback. The goal is to make it useful, not precious.